Long before I ever picked up the Lord of the Rings, the Hobbit had been a favorite book of mine. Like Bilbo, my life was comfortable, but I was also tormented by my own fears, sensitivities, and self-image. The Hobbit seemed to me like the ultimate story my life would have to follow for a happy ending. Although, much like Bilbo, I was aghast at the possibility of suffering and misfortune befalling me, the story arc of the book showed that embracing adventure and learning to leave behind the trepidation of the past was the only path to escape suffering. The transformation Bilbo undergoes taught me, time and time again from a young age, that fear was my true affliction and situations that scared me had the potential to be the most fulfilling.
My own path to overcoming these challenges also followed Bilbo's; although no wizards came knocking on my door and I set out on my adventures with aforethought (and a pocket handkerchief), throughout my formative years I sought out situations which pushed my comfort.
Standing on the side of the road for hours smiling big at each and every car speeding by while the arm sporting my upturned thumb starts to ache taught me not to fear the unknown. The unknown was from where my deliverance had to come - just like in wider life: the things that matter to us, the friends, occasions, lovers, and opportunities which shape our life and bring us joy can only come by chance when we are open to them.
The tale of the Hobbit will always feel like an essential part of me. I think that the idea of a creature as small and vulnerable seeming as a hobbit stepping up to the plate of life speaks to the child we all often feel like in scary and uncertain situations. If Bilbo can do it, why can't I?
These are the archives from 2010-2018 for the discussion forum hosted by the UNM Hobbit Society at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, NM, USA. The purpose of our group is to meet and associate with others interested in Tolkien, and to learn more about the author, his written works, and his sources through discussion, guest lectures and academically oriented activities. This blog is intended to expand discussion among UNM Hobbit Society members beyond what meeting times allow.
Thursday, September 6, 2018
Wednesday, September 5, 2018
The Hobbit: A Children's Book and More
The Hobbit is truly a children's book and yet is desirable to adults as well, for a truly unique adult still carries that child with them, that inner child that makes adult life so much more fun and far less drab too. The Hobbit is different than The Lord of the Rings because The Hobbit is a 'lesser' adventure rather than a 'greater' adventure. What I mean when I say 'greater' adventure compared to a 'lesser' adventure, I mean it in the way that a 'lesser' adventure can relate to a younger audience and usually has one plot line so that it does not lose the younger audience in the complexity of multi-plot adventures that I call a "greater' adventure. Children and young adults like adventures that they can relate to and have fun with. That is why The Hobbit to me is an adventure that kids can relate to and fantasize and dream about. That is why The Hobbit is written in a way that the characters in the novel interact with each other and follow a system of "playing by the rules". For at an early age, children are taught to play by the rules, follow the rules, that games have rules and that life has rules to be followed. Rules are set for children to know what the line is from right and wrong and how rules will help them become a better adult as they grow older. Rules are set for children. So, it would seem that was what J.R.R. Tolkien had in mind when he wrote The Hobbit and his children were the audience and the book would for other children around the world as well.
Guest Speaker: Betsy James
I went to the Guest Speaker series in the Honors forum this afternoon to hear all about one of our own professors here at UNM's Honor's College, none other than the author and illustrator, Betsy James. Betsy is a very cool and hip lady who has written some short stories, children's books, young adult books and has illustrated and painted beyond numerous works to her credit. She is an award winning writer of "The Seeker Series". She was born in Missouri and lived in Salt Lake City and graduated from the University of Utah. In high school, she was voted most likely to succeed, but then crashed and burned in an Ivy League school. Her father said she would be a waitress all of her life but she felt that wasn't her fate in life. She found a time capsule when she was 21 and in it were a painting, a rock with a hole in it that she found in California, and a letter written in her own blood stating, "I will be a writer!" She worked in Mexico as an illustrator on an archaeology site and became very interested in other cultures. She states that, "Writing is thinking aloud". She was a freelance illustrator and didn't publish her first book until she was 40. She teaches Speculative fiction here at the Honor's College, which is a mix of fantasy, science fiction, and horror ( and I truly admire and love this word 'speculative' for all the things that I have loved reading my entire life and wondered if there ever would be a category for them). She teaches World Building and Truth Flies and Other Fiction (I know one of my next classes that I will be taking here in Honors). She says the difference between fantasy and science fiction is one is "tits and rayguns" and the other is "elves and spandex", which I thoroughly enjoyed the humor there. She also said that another author quoted, "Sci-fi is logical extension of laws and science in imagined futures, fantasy is making money off of science fiction", which again I laughed hard at this very bright and hilarious lady who continued to amaze me through her speaking. She wrote an opening scene when she was very young for a book , but never wrote more. It was of a girl finding a seal man on the beach unconscious. She made a deal with herself to paint that scene until it changed for her. Every morning she asked for an image of the girl and the seal boy, and then paint whatever she imagined. These painting turned into over 350 and she entitled the collection 'Morning' describing what happened after the initial scene she started with. She has spent 25 years at the Zuni pueblo teaching workshops and again was deeply enriched by a culture that she was constantly around. She said, "Witn imagination, try imagining what it would be like to be in someone else's skin, in another body, and then a story will start to unravel for you". She also said, "Write unique stuff, for fiction is far more organic in nature". She is truly a kind soul and an artist too. This experience was quite enjoyable for me and I look forward to more.
The Hobbit a Children's book
Tolkien’s book The Hobbit is considered a children’s book because the use of language is simple enough to be understood by children but complex enough to challenge them to broaden their vocabulary. This use of simple language and a shorter narrative is very different from Tolkien’s other stories, specifically The Silmarillion and The Lord of the Rings which are both very long and use a higher vocabulary. The story is also very much a coming of age story. A young and immature individual (or at least young in comparison to the lifespan of a Hobbit) is thrown into an epic journey where his beliefs and way of life are challenged for the better ultimately resulting in a widening worldview and personal growth. This story archetype is usually aimed at 11 to 13-year-olds who are experiencing life-altering changes that require them to change certain worldview they may have had in their childhood and experience personal growth. I find that that the Hobbit for most normal boys and girls would be ideally read at this age because it would be at the age when it is most relatable. It was probably read sooner by a bunch of nerds, and I say that in the most loving way, who now obsess over all of Tolkien’s works. However, as Tolkien himself most cleverly said in his letter adults can extract even more from these so-called children’s stories and should therefore also read them
Relevance Post: Uniting Unique Communities
In class yesterday, some of the discussion included comments on different communities and the way that Bilbo found ways to relate with a lot of them. Being from the Shire, where everyone keeps to themselves and lead simple and happy lives, Bilbo had never experienced any other kind of community before setting off with Gandalf. However, by the time his journey ended, Bilbo had made friends with elves, dwarves, wizards, and even with Beorn. He had also communicated with creatures he didn't necessarily get along with (goblins and Gollum, for example). All of these new relationships made Bilbo a better and more refined Hobbit with a better sense of how big the world really is.
Personally, I know that I've often found myself wanting to stay in my own little world. I don't always want to meet new people, because I'm afraid it won't be worth the time. If I'm happy right where I am, why fix what isn't broken? But, when I do step beyond my comfort zone, I find myself learning from other people and their experiences and perspective. I find encouragement in camaraderie. I find inspiration in new ideas that I never would have come up with on my own. It's for these reasons that I enjoy taking classes and allowing my teachers to show me a broader world.
I think that each one of us in this class can relate to Bilbo in this way. We like to be in our comfort zones with the friends we've always had and the communities we feel we've built, but we also have an innate desire to branch out. We want to relate to other people who are unlike ourselves. We want to learn something new and experience fresh perspective. Sometimes, we don't get along with certain people, and that's ok. As long as we, like Bilbo, have an open mind and a kind heart to try to understanding different perspectives, we can broaden our horizons beyond our own little "Shire."
Personally, I know that I've often found myself wanting to stay in my own little world. I don't always want to meet new people, because I'm afraid it won't be worth the time. If I'm happy right where I am, why fix what isn't broken? But, when I do step beyond my comfort zone, I find myself learning from other people and their experiences and perspective. I find encouragement in camaraderie. I find inspiration in new ideas that I never would have come up with on my own. It's for these reasons that I enjoy taking classes and allowing my teachers to show me a broader world.
I think that each one of us in this class can relate to Bilbo in this way. We like to be in our comfort zones with the friends we've always had and the communities we feel we've built, but we also have an innate desire to branch out. We want to relate to other people who are unlike ourselves. We want to learn something new and experience fresh perspective. Sometimes, we don't get along with certain people, and that's ok. As long as we, like Bilbo, have an open mind and a kind heart to try to understanding different perspectives, we can broaden our horizons beyond our own little "Shire."
Tuesday, September 4, 2018
Alan Lee talking about his Tolkien Art and The Fall of Gondolin
An interesting article came out in The Guardian today about Alan Lee's journey into a career as a Tolkien artist and his work in the just released Fall of Gondolin:
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/sep/03/alan-lee-jrr-tolkien-the-lord-of-the-rings-the-hobbit-the-fall-of-gondolin?CMP=share_btn_tw.
Thoughts about what Lee says here? Any relationship to mythmaking suggested in this article?
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/sep/03/alan-lee-jrr-tolkien-the-lord-of-the-rings-the-hobbit-the-fall-of-gondolin?CMP=share_btn_tw.
Thoughts about what Lee says here? Any relationship to mythmaking suggested in this article?
Monday, September 3, 2018
The Power of Corruption: The Greed for Wealth
As we saw the epic struggle of power over the one ring in Lord of the Rings, we also saw the struggles of power over the desire and accumulation of treasure and wealth in The Hobbit. We saw how the craving of wealth and treasure for dragons became dominating and controlling factors as Smaug craved the power of wealth even though it was useless to them besides hoarding it and worshipping it. The whole tale is an adventure for treasure lost but looking to be reclaimed. We saw the ways of the Dwarven folk as a bit gruff and arrogant but still one of the friendly 'peoples' on Middle-earth. After regaining their ancient homeland, Thorin showed a side of himself that was slowly appearing through the adventure, and that was the lust for gold and jewels. Thorin nearly alienated himself from his dwarven friends and fellow adventurers after reclaiming the Dwarven treasure from Smaug. Not only was Thorin affected with lust and greed, but so were Bard and the humans from Dale and the elves too. It was a kind of greed for the power associated with great wealth that almost undid the forces of good when faced with an advancing army of evil orcs. So the line can blur between what is good and what is evil. Forces claiming to be good have been corrupted over time and have done evil deeds in the name of goodness because of the nature of greed and in the obtaining of treasure not rightfully their own. Do you think that if Thorin was never corrupted with that greed and it's undeniable lust for it, would the Battle of Five Armies turned out drastically different? Would the forces of good standing united together from the beginning against the evil threatening all of them have had less casualties and not such a tragic turn of events?
"On Fairy-stories": Children
In the "Children" section of J.R.R Tolkien's essay, "On Fairy-stories," two of the most important topics which he addresses is the misconception that fairy-stories are naturally for children and the functional desirability of a fairy-story.
Tolkien rants in this portion of his essay on the absurdity that fairy-stories are simply for children and that children are circumstantially better suited for digesting these tales of fantasy based on their own "credulity." Tolkien states that this very mindset leads to "artistic impairment" for the author. He even goes on to express his final judgment on the matter: the entire idea is "erroneous" or blatantly incorrect. Much is lost when a story is abridged or appropriated for a younger audience and Tolkien even believed that the things in a story which one might desire to shield a child from may not best be omitted but given to them anyway, and to let the merit of the story (dark and light) grow in them as they grow in their understanding.
Tolkien addresses the idea of "desirability" as a more pragmatic, utilitarian goal within the creative process, one that is a necessity to the success of a fairy-story. Following up on the previous point, Tolkien believed that the truly successful fairy-story is devoid of "adaptation," not merited by adults simply based on nostalgia or "sentiment," and the key to the lack of these vices is a tight-knit web of story. A story so engrossing and separate from the modern world of mankind that "subterfuge" is never required in order to continue believing the story.
Tolkien rants in this portion of his essay on the absurdity that fairy-stories are simply for children and that children are circumstantially better suited for digesting these tales of fantasy based on their own "credulity." Tolkien states that this very mindset leads to "artistic impairment" for the author. He even goes on to express his final judgment on the matter: the entire idea is "erroneous" or blatantly incorrect. Much is lost when a story is abridged or appropriated for a younger audience and Tolkien even believed that the things in a story which one might desire to shield a child from may not best be omitted but given to them anyway, and to let the merit of the story (dark and light) grow in them as they grow in their understanding.
Tolkien addresses the idea of "desirability" as a more pragmatic, utilitarian goal within the creative process, one that is a necessity to the success of a fairy-story. Following up on the previous point, Tolkien believed that the truly successful fairy-story is devoid of "adaptation," not merited by adults simply based on nostalgia or "sentiment," and the key to the lack of these vices is a tight-knit web of story. A story so engrossing and separate from the modern world of mankind that "subterfuge" is never required in order to continue believing the story.
Eönwë
Eönwë was the first to greet Eärendil on the shores of Valinor and brought him before the Valar to present his appeal. After Eärendil's request for the aid of the Valar in fighting against Morgoth was granted, Eönwë was sent to Middle-earth, as general of the Vanyar. Eönwë played a key role in the actions following the War of Wrath and the defeat of Morgoth: Eönwë took the remaining two Silmarils for safe keeping, but they were stolen by the remaining sons of Fëanor, and he did not permit them to be killed. In defeat, Sauron knelt to Eönwë and repented of his evil. But Eönwë had not the power to pardon Sauron's evil deeds and, therefore, commanded him to return to Aman to receive Manwë's judgment, but Sauron would not suffer such shame and punishment, so when Eönwë returned to Valinor, Sauron hid in Middle-earth festering in his evil.
When the Second Age began, Eönwë blessed the Houses of Edain with long life, wisdom, and power. The descendants of these houses became the High Men of Númenor.
Saturday, September 1, 2018
Introducing Uinen
Hello everyone!
My pseudonym is Uinen, The Lady of the Sea, from the Silmarillion. Uinen is the matron to all mariners and her hair lies spread throughout all waters. Her love is given to the creatures that live in salt streams and also the weeds that grow there. She is married to Ossë, a powerful spirit of the sea, who she is able to calm with her love. During the Second Age, the mariners of Númenór would cry to Uinen for help because of her ability to calm Ossë.
My pseudonym is Uinen, The Lady of the Sea, from the Silmarillion. Uinen is the matron to all mariners and her hair lies spread throughout all waters. Her love is given to the creatures that live in salt streams and also the weeds that grow there. She is married to Ossë, a powerful spirit of the sea, who she is able to calm with her love. During the Second Age, the mariners of Númenór would cry to Uinen for help because of her ability to calm Ossë.