Pages

Monday, December 10, 2018

Relevance Post- Songs and Bilbo

There is a song by Sleeping at Last (which, if you're not familiar with, please do yourself a favor and go listen to some of their stuff) called Pluto. I will share the lyrics below, but first a small comment. This song originally clicked with me because I have always felt afraid of feeling too much and showing too much. For a very long time I felt the need to close myself off, to the point where I was completely numb for several years, seemingly to the point of being "emotionally unavailable". However, lately I listened to it again after starting to be a lot more open and I saw a whole new meaning for the song. It isnt about being afraid, like I originally thought. It is about branching out and taking a leap of faith; much like Bilbo does when he agrees to be the (dear god I want to make a pun about Hobbits and  Hamburglar) thief for the dwarves. Just one more example of how music plays a huge part in the world of Tolkien... even decades after he has stopped writing about it.

"Pluto"

I woke up from the same dream:
Falling backwards, falling backwards
’Til it turned me inside out.

Now I live a waking life
Of looking backwards, looking backwards;
A model citizen of doubt.

Until one day I had enough
Of this exercise of trust.
I leaned in and let it hurt,
And let my body feel the dirt.
When I break pattern, I break ground.
I rebuild when I break down.
I wake up more awake than I’ve ever been before.

Still I’m pinned under the weight
Of what I believed would keep me safe.
So show me where my armor ends,
Show me where my skin begins.
Like a final puzzle piece
It all makes perfect sense to me…
The heaviness that I hold in my heart belongs to gravity.
The heaviness that I hold in my heart’s been crushing me.

I’ve been worried all my life,
A nervous wreck most of the time.
I’ve always been afraid of heights,
Of falling backwards, falling backwards.
I’ve been worried all my life.

’Til one day I had enough
Of this exercise of trust.
I leaned in and let it hurt,
Let my body feel the dirt.
When I break pattern, I break ground.
I rebuild when I break down.
I wake up more awake than I’ve ever been before.

Still I’m pinned under the weight
Of what I believed would keep me safe.
So show me where my armor ends,
Show me where my skin begins.
Like a final puzzle piece,
It all makes perfect sense to me…
The heaviness that I hold in my heart belongs to gravity.
The heaviness in my heart belongs to gravity.

{Nienna}

Sunday, December 9, 2018

Of Thingol and Melian


Love inspired by song

I think this story fits into the other works in that there is often an overlap with communication that isn’t directly language. Songs often hold more power than whole structured sentences and thoughts that the characters may have in a dialogue. I think that in this sense we go to the concept of what is universal, and that is communication. Whether it be written or verbal, in any language, containing numbers, communication is really what makes us conscious. I wanted to say human but animals also communicate if not in the way that we do. We are able to express complex and often abstract emotions, retell events, remember, hope for the future, wonder, and imagine all through communication. And I think that Tolkien was conscious of this and was very deliberate in his inclusion of music to make us feel things and evoke certain moods and relay ideas into his works, breathing life and spirit into them.
On another note, there is also the mention of love that is born of a beautiful song. And although romantic love isn’t altogether common in his works, Tolkien definitely makes it clear that affection and trust *two vital ingredients for love, in y opinion) are not lacking in his characters. Real connection and empathy is forged between the characters and it makes them stronger and makes them act in a way that is usually beneficial for all involved. Indeed, it seems that it is only when there is a lack of this compassion that we see corruption and evil come to pass. When people consider themselves to be the most important, beautiful, or qualified, the integrity of all that surrounds the falls apart quite quickly.
Additionally, it seems that there is the inclusion of communication with birds In this chapter, with nightingales. This is very similar to several scenes in The Hobbit that include crows/ravens and thrushes and the ability for some people to understand them so that there can be a continuation of plot and development of the story. This leads to the downfall of Smaug and the success of the Men and Elves. Unfortunately it also led to the death of Thorin.
I am still perplexed at the whole “made a better version of men and elves than before” bit. Shouldn’t the elves already have been perfect? But also, shouldn’t the creation of a new being with a Valar have corrupted that perfection?

{Nienna}

Freewrite (LOTR Book V)

The following is my freewrite about Hope and Despair. Pardon the fact that I switched languages in the middle, that's why there are so many typos:

I chose the scene in (chapter 5 I think) where Theoden lets out a loud battle cry at seeing the destruction of Mini Tirith upon arriving with the Rohirrim. They have just stumbled upon two bodies and have realized that the people probably thought they woud not come to aid them. I think this cry isn’t quite despair, but it isn’t hope either. It is pure rebellion. A sort of courage that pushed Theoden to let forth a spirit of “i wont give up, even as the odds are entirely stacked against us and we feel as though there is no more battle because we have all been destroyed.” It seems to shake his companions as well, becuase it is sudden but very full of emotion. A sort of phantom remnant of their compratiorts and alies; their hopes, their lives, their struggles. It is the summation of the struggle thus far and a huge FUCK YOU to whateber challenges lay ahead. They do not have hope per se at this point, they have stubbornness and pride, impulandolos hacia la victoria, por lo menos sobre si mismos y la desesperacion de la derrota. Empece a escribir en el idioma que no es, ups. Estoy pensando que este momento parece llegar de la nada, hace unos momentos estaban con un grupo de personas que parecían no ser reales, ya que se piensa que el grupo había desaparecido hace tiempo. Pero persisten y los llevan por un camino que nadie mas conoce. Me hace pensar que no eran reales, simplemente individuos que existen como ecos del pasado y que tratan de inspirar a las personas del presente hacia sus metas .Es una metáfora de la historia y la identidad; algo que jamas se puede borrar (en teoría) y que en alguna forma u otra, continua dejando huella en el future, a pesar de las derrotas y los problemas que se posan frente nosotros. Ese grito que da Theoden me parece un sentimiento que todos experimentamos en un momento u otro. Tiene un sabor de enojo y tristeza, pero mas que nada es como una nube que necesitamos sacar para quedar mas ligeros y continuar la batalla. Y eso es lo importante de esta escena; que todo parece perdido pero solo da una razón mas para no preocuparse de los obstáculos.

{Nienna}

Farewells and New Beginnings

I just wanted to thank everyone in the class, including Dr. Donovan and J.R.R. Tolkien, for giving me such a wondrous experience that I will cherish until the end of time. This class was the best I have ever taken and conversing about Tolkien with all the awesome young minds was the experience of a lifetime for me. I had so much fun talking about who the man Tolkien was and about his legendary works of fantasy. This call not only taught me so much about Tolkien that I didn't know, but it also reawakened a dream that was lost to me long ago and now realized again because of all of you. Never in my life would I have imagined taking a class like this and this was the most awesome class ever with the best classmates a man could ask for; as well as the most spectacular professor and human being that I have ever been privileged to learn from. These past couple days have been a bit mournful because I realize the class is actually over and our times are over with. My favorite two days have now become a bit more mundane. Thanks to you all, I now have my calling truly focused on and writing is all I shall do from here on out. You all gave me the inspiration to follow my dream and one day down the road soon, please look for my novel on bookstore shelves near you. I assure you that I will follow my dream this time and entertain the world with my own creative fantasy stories. Again, thank you all and you all will be sorely missed by me.

Dwarves

One of my personal favorite races in Middle-earth is the dwarvish race. The dwarves are very sturdy creatures who don't take orders from anyone (except from Gandalf). It is interesting to me how these underground dwellers are not evil. They spend most of their lives in caves and mines but unlike goblins which do do similar things, are not evil creatures but are generally good creatures. Tolkien, as far as I'm aware, was not the first person to create a dwarf but the concept still fascinates me. Tolkien in general liked to keep with themes for his creatures. The elves who are supposed to be the mightiest, are the most connected to nature and their own abilities. Them being connected to nature unlike their counter part, the orcs shows that the elves are good for using nature instead of the 'evil' machines the orcs use. Dwarves mine in middle earth and I would assume they have developed tools to help them mine efficiently over the ages. They however are not evil. Despite Being from underground, being stout and borderline fierce, the dwarves are not an evil race which interests me. With all the 'evil' characteristics, why did Tolkien not make the dwarves evil?

Relevance Post: Languages

Okay, just one more post.

So I was at a party tonight with some linguistics majors and a lot of what they were talking about pretty directly related to the way Tolkien described the development of different Elvish languages.

We were mostly talking about the similarity of different languages: for example:

1. English and French
This similarity comes from the fact that the Norman French (a Viking culture who invaded Normandy) got bored of France and invaded England instead. Okay, this is not really how this happened but bear with me. I included a super cool example about how the English language changed below, and we can still sometimes understand lots of French cognates.



2. Arabic and Hebrew
This one I wasn't familiar with, but my friend who has been taking Arabic classes for about 6 years was telling me that when he watched this one show (where some characters spoke Hebrew and some spoke Arabic) that it was hard to even tell which language was being spoken without the subtitles on.

3. French and Italian
This then led to a series of anecdotes that reminded me of one of my own: I have a coworker at Satellite named Mara who speaks Italian. She can understand when my manager is speaking Spanish (usually complaining secretly about customers), but I can't. I can, however, understand when she tells me what he said in Italian, even though I only speak French. As a group, we play a pretty regular game of telephone from French to Italian to Spanish and back.


This just reminds me greatly of the fabricated language development Tolkien used, and I can understand why, especially as a European who was (I'm making a wild assumption here) in contact with several more languages regularly than many Americans.

Mythmaking comparison

I was thinking the other day about the three texts we looked at about Tolkien's thoughts on mythmaking. Three different formats, three different tones, one message. I will admit that Leaf by Niggle was the text that confused me the most out of the three... I am not sure if it's because my brain captures messages better with the rambling format Tolkien had in On Fairy Stories and Mythopeia or if I had not the brain power for a cute little story at the end of the semester. Either way, I found it much harder to focus and understand the intention of Leaf by Niggle and its role in explaining mythmaking.

Mythopeia was probably my favorite of the three, which suprised me, seeing as how I am not a fan of poetry in many cases. Yet there was something hypnotic about the text that called to me and opened a new world in which I was the words creating a story, I was every mystery and creature, and I felt as if every universe could exist all at once and not at all, as soon as I blinked myself back into reality. Mythopeia was undoubtledly also a clap-back so like, mood. I definitely felt more in tune with it.

On Fairy Stories was my second favorite, because I am similar to Tolkien in my fascination of Faerie and its inhabitants. Reading his exploration of the topic gave me a lot more questions to think about, and although I know that can frustrate and confuse a lot of people, it makes me feel a sense of fulfillment and curiosity that pushes me toward more answers.

After experiencing all three texts and analyzing Tolkien's applications of this theory, I feel much more familiar with the concepts and delve much deeper into his stories without having to scramble in my brain to understand background implications

{Nienna}

Relevance Post

So, I shared this idea with a few of our classmates. They told me it was a bit of a stretch, so I thought I'd share it with y'all and see what you think. So with no further ado: Tolkien's works show many instances of unlikely groupings of characters. The entire Fellowship, Bilbo and all the dwarves, Beorn (with anyone tbh), etc. Most of the characters in Tolkien's works would be content continuing their everyday lives, specifically without interacting with characters of other races. I found this to be very reflective of people. People, in my experience, don't like to be with people who aren't like them. However, certain outside factors can cause different kinds of people to interact with other kinds. In the legendarium, it's for the greater good, basically. But in real life, it is mostly just forced upon us. So really, I guess, I'm just trying to point out the fact that Tolkien really really REALLY tried to write relatable content into his work.       

Relevance Post: Eat Thy Toast

So this weekend, I spent quite a lot time thinking about food. It started because I, along with some friends, took a road trip to get food. We all wanted food that just doesn't exist in New Mexico, so we went Amarillo, TX. In the end, I ate/drink something from 6 different locations. I then began thinking about my regular day eating habits. Up until recently, I fasted in the morning and then ate about ever two hours. I realized soon thereafter that Hobbits eat six times a day, which is roughly every two hours! So this road trip to Amarillo made me realize that I am secretly a Hobbit.  

Relevance Post: Types of Elves

I was hanging out with a couple of people yesterday and we discussed what type of elf each of us would be. We established that one of my friends- a tall and graceful young woman- would be a Tolkien elf because she matches the physical and emotional description. Another one of my friends is most similar to Buddy the elf, because she has a crazy love for sugar and Christmas! The last 3 people in my group hang out all the time and were most like Snap, Crackle, and Pop from Rice Krispies. What type of elf do you think you guys are?