I have been thinking recently about how the story of the Children of Húrin is one of the Silmarillion's most tragic stories. While Tolkein's essay on Fairy Stories details the necessity for Fantasy to be intertwined with joy, the story of Túrin is anything but joyful. While this seems contradictory, and it may be, I do think that the tragic nature of the story is what makes it an important piece of Tolkein's mythical puzzle. Joy cannot exist in the world without tragedy, and the same notion applies in Tolkein's created world. Túrin's story mirrors Greek tragedy myths. This must have been purposeful as Tolkein was creating a myth. Anyway, the thing I've taken away from my musings on the sad story of the Children of Húrin is that Tolkein's mission was to create a world where joy can exist both in it and outside of it (by affecting the reader). And in order to do so, tragic stories are inevitable.
What are your thoughts on joy and tragedy in the Silmarillion? (if you've read any of it)
These are the archives from 2010-2018 for the discussion forum hosted by the UNM Hobbit Society at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, NM, USA. The purpose of our group is to meet and associate with others interested in Tolkien, and to learn more about the author, his written works, and his sources through discussion, guest lectures and academically oriented activities. This blog is intended to expand discussion among UNM Hobbit Society members beyond what meeting times allow.
Friday, August 31, 2018
The Power of Imagination
The human, and likely non-human, brain is able to form images of things that are not real but are what we often call “made-up.” These images may be vivid, single, lasting, big or small. These made up images transcend us into alternate universes and it is our imagination that holds these stories within it. The imagination is much more complex than one might assume, and Tolkien largely relates the human imagination to the creation and operation of fantasy. Through their imagination, the reader is able to transport themselves into a different time and place that is somewhat like what is already known to them, in some ways it resembles reality. Imagination is powerful. Imagination is able to transcend time and space. Imagination is an art form. Imagination is much more complex than just a passing train of thought, but it has the ability to change lives and mindsets. Imagination is important when it comes to fantasies because people often think of fantasies as a passage out of the “Primary World” or as an escape, although the thought of it being an “escape” from reality is not universally accepted like we have addressed many times in class. Why might this be? Because the body is stuck in reality while only the mind is able to transcend into the imagination. The mind and body, as separate as they may seem, are bound together. What happens in the mind often affects the actions of the body, and because the body is stuck in reality, what happens in the imagination, therefore, affects the whole person. The imagination is so important because it allows for the transportation of mind and the changing of the body.
Thursday, August 30, 2018
Nessa: The Power of a Name
My pseudonym is Nessa which comes from the Quenya neth ("young"). She is called the Dancer and is a Queen of the Valar. Two earlier names for Nessa were Helinyetille, the "Eyes of Heartsease", from helin ("violet, pansy") and Melesta, from mele ("to love"). She is the sister of Örome. She married Tulkas the Strong in the Spring of Arda. Lithe and swift of foot and always appearing young, she loved running with the deer and was faster than them. Before the Isle of Almaren was destroyed, she loved dancing the green fields of Almaren, which was the first home to the Valar. Later she continued her dances on the always beautifully green grasses of Valnor. Nessa and Tulkas' household was always lively and full of good times and revelry, she would be known to serve wine to her husband and his great warrior champions after their bouts of strength and other feats. After the Ñolder fled to Middle-earth, Nessa and most of the other Valar desired the same peace and quiet they had during their ancient days of Valinor. Wishing to be away from Melkor and the Ñolder, the Valar choose the Hiding of Valinor to assure their people and way of life would remain safe and in peaceful harmony.
On Fairy-stories freewrites
Click on the Comments link below to enter your "On Fairy-stories" freewrite from class. If you wish to comment on someone else's freewrite, please include that person's pseudonym in your response. For example-- "In Butterbur's freewrite, he said..."
The Corruption of Power
J.R.R Tolkien wrote his epic saga during the time of the Great Wars that plagued Europe. He wrote them as a sort of escape from the horrendous atrocities seen in wars of that magnitude. Do you think that he was warning his readers of how power corrupts and can destroy in the world we live in and wanted the people in the world to be cautious of the influence that power holds over the mortal soul? Tolkien saw the advancement of Nazi Germany under Hitler and the evils associated with the desire for power. It seems to me that he was seeing a pattern of how power can be used wrongly and the effects it has on the innocent bystanders of warring nations. It has only gotten worse in the modern age as power has become nefarious in its use by individuals, by corporations and countries too and seems to be heading society down a very dark path. This needed to be changed in order for a more peaceful and progressive age for all the people on this planet.
Wednesday, August 29, 2018
A Dichotomy
I find that in the "Children" section of the essay the two most important concepts are that of the role of the child as well as the role of the adult. While being mundane concepts, they carry an exceptional amount of weight in the presented argument. These two concepts are discussed almost as a prearranged dichotomy, in terms of their relations with "fairy stories." Children are allowed to hear, read, and watch "fairy stories" as entertainment. While Adults are not, being that "fairy stories" are perceived as juvenile. In the discussion surrounding this fracture, it does not seem apparent that there is a substantial amount of over lap. However, it is also discussed that there is much more to be had from "fairy stories" than the novelty presented to children. This dichotomy is presented in an effort to accomplish two things. One of which being: an attempt to sway adults to give "fairy stories" their rightful place as important parts of literature. The second, an attempt to show case the fact that "fairy stories" are changed and convoluted to be interpreted as children's stories.
On Magic, Allegory, and Mythology
In our overall discussion of Tolkien's, "On Fairy-stories", quite a few people mentioned that Tolkien seemed to believe Faerie ought to be enchanted, but not extravagantly so, and that any magic within Faerie should be treated as if it were normal and generally accepted by the characters within it (the story). This bit of insight helped complete my understanding of Tolkien's purposes.
Initially I knew from my portion of the text that Tolkien thought of allegory (nature myths), mythology, and history, as being a part of the same "thread". Underlying each seems to consistently be some truth about the human condition, namely the curse of temptation. This portion makes a great deal of sense if one considers things the way Tolkien did: Stories of the truth of the human experience are invented, reinvented, passed along, altered (either in general nature or in ending), yet tend to revolve around characters that are personified or are inspired by Man. Unfortunately, it wasn't so clear to me why Tolkien was so displeased with Faerie--critiquing it more than praising it.
Again, our discussion made clear the fact that Tolkien seems to believe that Faerie would be better off if it didn't extraordinarily exist, in its own right, and if man were not the obvious creators or protagonists within it (although he was fine with subtle allegory and meaning). What makes Faerie magical is not the fact that it encompasses characters or creatures outside of what we will ever see, but that in reading or observing Faerie, we get to feel like we are in another type of reality. Other things exist that are bigger than we are, with different legend, and we get to be inhabitants of a new place.
Initially I knew from my portion of the text that Tolkien thought of allegory (nature myths), mythology, and history, as being a part of the same "thread". Underlying each seems to consistently be some truth about the human condition, namely the curse of temptation. This portion makes a great deal of sense if one considers things the way Tolkien did: Stories of the truth of the human experience are invented, reinvented, passed along, altered (either in general nature or in ending), yet tend to revolve around characters that are personified or are inspired by Man. Unfortunately, it wasn't so clear to me why Tolkien was so displeased with Faerie--critiquing it more than praising it.
Again, our discussion made clear the fact that Tolkien seems to believe that Faerie would be better off if it didn't extraordinarily exist, in its own right, and if man were not the obvious creators or protagonists within it (although he was fine with subtle allegory and meaning). What makes Faerie magical is not the fact that it encompasses characters or creatures outside of what we will ever see, but that in reading or observing Faerie, we get to feel like we are in another type of reality. Other things exist that are bigger than we are, with different legend, and we get to be inhabitants of a new place.
Tuesday, August 28, 2018
For Children of All Ages
In Tolkien's essay, "Tree and Leaf," he challenges the prevalent yet subconscious assumption that fairy-tales are written for children. He asks his readers to consider why the connection between children and fairy-tales has been so widely accepted.
Children have the capacity for blind faith. They trust their authorities and the words of older people, because they haven't lived long enough to learn the art of questioning others. Maybe we associate children with fairy-tales because they can experience the "magic" of being transported into another world. They don't feel the need to question fantasy and myth; they simply believe it. Or, at least, they are willing to let their minds experience it without question.
Even though Tolkien disputes the automatic association of children with fairy-tales, perhaps children are able teach the older generation how to experience fairy-tale "magic" by example. With the acceptance of a little blind faith, adults could experience the wonder of fantasy in fiction just like their younger counterparts.
Children have the capacity for blind faith. They trust their authorities and the words of older people, because they haven't lived long enough to learn the art of questioning others. Maybe we associate children with fairy-tales because they can experience the "magic" of being transported into another world. They don't feel the need to question fantasy and myth; they simply believe it. Or, at least, they are willing to let their minds experience it without question.
Even though Tolkien disputes the automatic association of children with fairy-tales, perhaps children are able teach the older generation how to experience fairy-tale "magic" by example. With the acceptance of a little blind faith, adults could experience the wonder of fantasy in fiction just like their younger counterparts.
Background on Vairë
Hello Green Dragon readers,
Per Dr. Donovan's suggestion of writing about our pseudonyms, I would like to give some background on the character of Vairë from the Silmarillion. Vairë was a queen of the Valar and the spouse of Mandos. She is called The Weaver because she weaves all things in Time into her webs which clothe the ever widening halls of Mandos. She essentially weaves together the fabric of time and space into a story to decorate the halls of Mandos.
Per Dr. Donovan's suggestion of writing about our pseudonyms, I would like to give some background on the character of Vairë from the Silmarillion. Vairë was a queen of the Valar and the spouse of Mandos. She is called The Weaver because she weaves all things in Time into her webs which clothe the ever widening halls of Mandos. She essentially weaves together the fabric of time and space into a story to decorate the halls of Mandos.
![]() |
| https://www.pinterest.com/pin/534521049514835783/ |
Tolkien and Power
For starters giving me very little guidelines for what I must write in my blogs and giving me a pseudonym is giving me way too much power, I like it. On that same note, I would like to discuss Tolkien’s use of power in his story as described by him in his Letter to Milton Waldman. Tolkien says that the word power in his books always carries a negative connotation, the only exception is when its associated with the Valar (@me). We can see this most clearly in “The ring of Power”, this ring holds extraordinary power and gives the wielder the power to accomplish all his wildest dreams, but we must be wary since this ring will corrupt the wielders purest wishes into a Machiavellian endeavor. This is an interesting view of power since in our modern American values having power is always a good thing, we have sayings like “knowledge is power” in order to motivate children to learn. However, there is also the not so positive and often not talked about the assumption that with money comes power. Does this mean that our perception of power comes from innocence and our faith in humanity’s innate goodness or was Tolkien oversimplifying the role of power in a society?
Monday, August 27, 2018
Central Elements in Mythologies
List and discuss two specific elements of any kind of real-world mythology or fictional world that you think are particularly central or important to it. Why do these elements strike you as particularly interesting or important? What do these two elements say about the culture that gave rise to them?
Your Pseudonym
You have been given the name of a figure from Tolkien's Middle-earth mythology to use as your pseudonym for work on this blog. Look up your pseudonym and write a brief description of who/what your mythological character is. Tell us whatever you can learn of the story of your character. If you really get inspired, feel free to add an image to your description!
