Pages

Monday, December 10, 2018

Relevance Post- Songs and Bilbo

There is a song by Sleeping at Last (which, if you're not familiar with, please do yourself a favor and go listen to some of their stuff) called Pluto. I will share the lyrics below, but first a small comment. This song originally clicked with me because I have always felt afraid of feeling too much and showing too much. For a very long time I felt the need to close myself off, to the point where I was completely numb for several years, seemingly to the point of being "emotionally unavailable". However, lately I listened to it again after starting to be a lot more open and I saw a whole new meaning for the song. It isnt about being afraid, like I originally thought. It is about branching out and taking a leap of faith; much like Bilbo does when he agrees to be the (dear god I want to make a pun about Hobbits and  Hamburglar) thief for the dwarves. Just one more example of how music plays a huge part in the world of Tolkien... even decades after he has stopped writing about it.

"Pluto"

I woke up from the same dream:
Falling backwards, falling backwards
’Til it turned me inside out.

Now I live a waking life
Of looking backwards, looking backwards;
A model citizen of doubt.

Until one day I had enough
Of this exercise of trust.
I leaned in and let it hurt,
And let my body feel the dirt.
When I break pattern, I break ground.
I rebuild when I break down.
I wake up more awake than I’ve ever been before.

Still I’m pinned under the weight
Of what I believed would keep me safe.
So show me where my armor ends,
Show me where my skin begins.
Like a final puzzle piece
It all makes perfect sense to me…
The heaviness that I hold in my heart belongs to gravity.
The heaviness that I hold in my heart’s been crushing me.

I’ve been worried all my life,
A nervous wreck most of the time.
I’ve always been afraid of heights,
Of falling backwards, falling backwards.
I’ve been worried all my life.

’Til one day I had enough
Of this exercise of trust.
I leaned in and let it hurt,
Let my body feel the dirt.
When I break pattern, I break ground.
I rebuild when I break down.
I wake up more awake than I’ve ever been before.

Still I’m pinned under the weight
Of what I believed would keep me safe.
So show me where my armor ends,
Show me where my skin begins.
Like a final puzzle piece,
It all makes perfect sense to me…
The heaviness that I hold in my heart belongs to gravity.
The heaviness in my heart belongs to gravity.

{Nienna}

Sunday, December 9, 2018

Of Thingol and Melian


Love inspired by song

I think this story fits into the other works in that there is often an overlap with communication that isn’t directly language. Songs often hold more power than whole structured sentences and thoughts that the characters may have in a dialogue. I think that in this sense we go to the concept of what is universal, and that is communication. Whether it be written or verbal, in any language, containing numbers, communication is really what makes us conscious. I wanted to say human but animals also communicate if not in the way that we do. We are able to express complex and often abstract emotions, retell events, remember, hope for the future, wonder, and imagine all through communication. And I think that Tolkien was conscious of this and was very deliberate in his inclusion of music to make us feel things and evoke certain moods and relay ideas into his works, breathing life and spirit into them.
On another note, there is also the mention of love that is born of a beautiful song. And although romantic love isn’t altogether common in his works, Tolkien definitely makes it clear that affection and trust *two vital ingredients for love, in y opinion) are not lacking in his characters. Real connection and empathy is forged between the characters and it makes them stronger and makes them act in a way that is usually beneficial for all involved. Indeed, it seems that it is only when there is a lack of this compassion that we see corruption and evil come to pass. When people consider themselves to be the most important, beautiful, or qualified, the integrity of all that surrounds the falls apart quite quickly.
Additionally, it seems that there is the inclusion of communication with birds In this chapter, with nightingales. This is very similar to several scenes in The Hobbit that include crows/ravens and thrushes and the ability for some people to understand them so that there can be a continuation of plot and development of the story. This leads to the downfall of Smaug and the success of the Men and Elves. Unfortunately it also led to the death of Thorin.
I am still perplexed at the whole “made a better version of men and elves than before” bit. Shouldn’t the elves already have been perfect? But also, shouldn’t the creation of a new being with a Valar have corrupted that perfection?

{Nienna}

Freewrite (LOTR Book V)

The following is my freewrite about Hope and Despair. Pardon the fact that I switched languages in the middle, that's why there are so many typos:

I chose the scene in (chapter 5 I think) where Theoden lets out a loud battle cry at seeing the destruction of Mini Tirith upon arriving with the Rohirrim. They have just stumbled upon two bodies and have realized that the people probably thought they woud not come to aid them. I think this cry isn’t quite despair, but it isn’t hope either. It is pure rebellion. A sort of courage that pushed Theoden to let forth a spirit of “i wont give up, even as the odds are entirely stacked against us and we feel as though there is no more battle because we have all been destroyed.” It seems to shake his companions as well, becuase it is sudden but very full of emotion. A sort of phantom remnant of their compratiorts and alies; their hopes, their lives, their struggles. It is the summation of the struggle thus far and a huge FUCK YOU to whateber challenges lay ahead. They do not have hope per se at this point, they have stubbornness and pride, impulandolos hacia la victoria, por lo menos sobre si mismos y la desesperacion de la derrota. Empece a escribir en el idioma que no es, ups. Estoy pensando que este momento parece llegar de la nada, hace unos momentos estaban con un grupo de personas que parecían no ser reales, ya que se piensa que el grupo había desaparecido hace tiempo. Pero persisten y los llevan por un camino que nadie mas conoce. Me hace pensar que no eran reales, simplemente individuos que existen como ecos del pasado y que tratan de inspirar a las personas del presente hacia sus metas .Es una metáfora de la historia y la identidad; algo que jamas se puede borrar (en teoría) y que en alguna forma u otra, continua dejando huella en el future, a pesar de las derrotas y los problemas que se posan frente nosotros. Ese grito que da Theoden me parece un sentimiento que todos experimentamos en un momento u otro. Tiene un sabor de enojo y tristeza, pero mas que nada es como una nube que necesitamos sacar para quedar mas ligeros y continuar la batalla. Y eso es lo importante de esta escena; que todo parece perdido pero solo da una razón mas para no preocuparse de los obstáculos.

{Nienna}

Farewells and New Beginnings

I just wanted to thank everyone in the class, including Dr. Donovan and J.R.R. Tolkien, for giving me such a wondrous experience that I will cherish until the end of time. This class was the best I have ever taken and conversing about Tolkien with all the awesome young minds was the experience of a lifetime for me. I had so much fun talking about who the man Tolkien was and about his legendary works of fantasy. This call not only taught me so much about Tolkien that I didn't know, but it also reawakened a dream that was lost to me long ago and now realized again because of all of you. Never in my life would I have imagined taking a class like this and this was the most awesome class ever with the best classmates a man could ask for; as well as the most spectacular professor and human being that I have ever been privileged to learn from. These past couple days have been a bit mournful because I realize the class is actually over and our times are over with. My favorite two days have now become a bit more mundane. Thanks to you all, I now have my calling truly focused on and writing is all I shall do from here on out. You all gave me the inspiration to follow my dream and one day down the road soon, please look for my novel on bookstore shelves near you. I assure you that I will follow my dream this time and entertain the world with my own creative fantasy stories. Again, thank you all and you all will be sorely missed by me.

Dwarves

One of my personal favorite races in Middle-earth is the dwarvish race. The dwarves are very sturdy creatures who don't take orders from anyone (except from Gandalf). It is interesting to me how these underground dwellers are not evil. They spend most of their lives in caves and mines but unlike goblins which do do similar things, are not evil creatures but are generally good creatures. Tolkien, as far as I'm aware, was not the first person to create a dwarf but the concept still fascinates me. Tolkien in general liked to keep with themes for his creatures. The elves who are supposed to be the mightiest, are the most connected to nature and their own abilities. Them being connected to nature unlike their counter part, the orcs shows that the elves are good for using nature instead of the 'evil' machines the orcs use. Dwarves mine in middle earth and I would assume they have developed tools to help them mine efficiently over the ages. They however are not evil. Despite Being from underground, being stout and borderline fierce, the dwarves are not an evil race which interests me. With all the 'evil' characteristics, why did Tolkien not make the dwarves evil?

Relevance Post: Languages

Okay, just one more post.

So I was at a party tonight with some linguistics majors and a lot of what they were talking about pretty directly related to the way Tolkien described the development of different Elvish languages.

We were mostly talking about the similarity of different languages: for example:

1. English and French
This similarity comes from the fact that the Norman French (a Viking culture who invaded Normandy) got bored of France and invaded England instead. Okay, this is not really how this happened but bear with me. I included a super cool example about how the English language changed below, and we can still sometimes understand lots of French cognates.



2. Arabic and Hebrew
This one I wasn't familiar with, but my friend who has been taking Arabic classes for about 6 years was telling me that when he watched this one show (where some characters spoke Hebrew and some spoke Arabic) that it was hard to even tell which language was being spoken without the subtitles on.

3. French and Italian
This then led to a series of anecdotes that reminded me of one of my own: I have a coworker at Satellite named Mara who speaks Italian. She can understand when my manager is speaking Spanish (usually complaining secretly about customers), but I can't. I can, however, understand when she tells me what he said in Italian, even though I only speak French. As a group, we play a pretty regular game of telephone from French to Italian to Spanish and back.


This just reminds me greatly of the fabricated language development Tolkien used, and I can understand why, especially as a European who was (I'm making a wild assumption here) in contact with several more languages regularly than many Americans.

Mythmaking comparison

I was thinking the other day about the three texts we looked at about Tolkien's thoughts on mythmaking. Three different formats, three different tones, one message. I will admit that Leaf by Niggle was the text that confused me the most out of the three... I am not sure if it's because my brain captures messages better with the rambling format Tolkien had in On Fairy Stories and Mythopeia or if I had not the brain power for a cute little story at the end of the semester. Either way, I found it much harder to focus and understand the intention of Leaf by Niggle and its role in explaining mythmaking.

Mythopeia was probably my favorite of the three, which suprised me, seeing as how I am not a fan of poetry in many cases. Yet there was something hypnotic about the text that called to me and opened a new world in which I was the words creating a story, I was every mystery and creature, and I felt as if every universe could exist all at once and not at all, as soon as I blinked myself back into reality. Mythopeia was undoubtledly also a clap-back so like, mood. I definitely felt more in tune with it.

On Fairy Stories was my second favorite, because I am similar to Tolkien in my fascination of Faerie and its inhabitants. Reading his exploration of the topic gave me a lot more questions to think about, and although I know that can frustrate and confuse a lot of people, it makes me feel a sense of fulfillment and curiosity that pushes me toward more answers.

After experiencing all three texts and analyzing Tolkien's applications of this theory, I feel much more familiar with the concepts and delve much deeper into his stories without having to scramble in my brain to understand background implications

{Nienna}

Relevance Post

So, I shared this idea with a few of our classmates. They told me it was a bit of a stretch, so I thought I'd share it with y'all and see what you think. So with no further ado: Tolkien's works show many instances of unlikely groupings of characters. The entire Fellowship, Bilbo and all the dwarves, Beorn (with anyone tbh), etc. Most of the characters in Tolkien's works would be content continuing their everyday lives, specifically without interacting with characters of other races. I found this to be very reflective of people. People, in my experience, don't like to be with people who aren't like them. However, certain outside factors can cause different kinds of people to interact with other kinds. In the legendarium, it's for the greater good, basically. But in real life, it is mostly just forced upon us. So really, I guess, I'm just trying to point out the fact that Tolkien really really REALLY tried to write relatable content into his work.       

Relevance Post: Eat Thy Toast

So this weekend, I spent quite a lot time thinking about food. It started because I, along with some friends, took a road trip to get food. We all wanted food that just doesn't exist in New Mexico, so we went Amarillo, TX. In the end, I ate/drink something from 6 different locations. I then began thinking about my regular day eating habits. Up until recently, I fasted in the morning and then ate about ever two hours. I realized soon thereafter that Hobbits eat six times a day, which is roughly every two hours! So this road trip to Amarillo made me realize that I am secretly a Hobbit.  

Relevance Post: Types of Elves

I was hanging out with a couple of people yesterday and we discussed what type of elf each of us would be. We established that one of my friends- a tall and graceful young woman- would be a Tolkien elf because she matches the physical and emotional description. Another one of my friends is most similar to Buddy the elf, because she has a crazy love for sugar and Christmas! The last 3 people in my group hang out all the time and were most like Snap, Crackle, and Pop from Rice Krispies. What type of elf do you think you guys are?

Speaker- Eric Valhagen

I went to the event on Friday night with fantasy artist Eric Valhagen. He spoke to us about his process in creating images of fantasy worlds and about how this had an impact on his life. He asked if any of us were artists and being the self-conscious potato that I am, I did not raise my hand. He gave us several tips on how to be successful-- even if we were not artists. He said that "the more experience you acquire, build on it" because no matter how small of an experience you had, it was still learning and improvement.

He also offered a way to improve self-worth by posing the question "why doesn't it work" and try to fix that instead of simply saying "that's shit". To me, this would have been a great technique for Niggle to finish his work. If he had been able to change perspectives to finish his work, he would not have been so frustrated. Then again, it was his inability to finish it in life that led to him improving so much once he got to Niggle's Parish. As Velhagen said "If you won't stand by your artwork, then who else will?"

{Nienna}

Hobbit Society

This past Friday, I got the honor of listening to Eric Velhagen explain and answer questions about his fantasy artwork. We started off the evening by being frustrated with the pizza not being delivered on time, but once we started the actual meeting, we were enthralled by Eric's work and stories. Eric told us about how he was given about 6 months to paint for each month of The Game of Thrones calendar and how The Wizards of the Coast (the company that owns Magic the Gathering) contacted him with very specific requests for the cards they asked him to design. While Eric was introducing himself, he passed around prints of some of his work and told us about their names and interesting facts about each one. My favorite 2 were called Knight Lights and Felines! Eric also has specific Lord of the Rings artwork that was just amazing! I would highly suggest going on to his website (https://ericvelhagen.carbonmade.com/) and checking out the Glorfindel and the Balrog painting. It was amazing to meet him and hear how he turned his passion into a lifestyle!

Saturday, December 8, 2018

Endings

As all of us know, the ending to Lord of the Rings is one of the most masterful endings in the history of epic fantasy.  Frodo arriving at Mount Doom to destroy the Ring after his incredible journey, only to fall victim to it; our hero failing but redeeming himself through Gollum's wretchedness all have theological implications. The ending has such an obvious poetic irony, one would expect that Tolkien had the whole event planned to the letter since the beginning. But we know that is not the case. Tolkien played with the ending for a long time and even submitted the manuscript with a completely different ending than the one we know and love (I recommend looking it up because it's pretty unrecognizable). 
With the semester coming to a bittersweet end, I thought it fitting to make a post about one of the greatest endings in literature. It's upsetting, but fitting; sad but profoundly joyful, like the ending of this class. So my final question to all of you is: is there a way you think of to improve the already magnificent ending of Lord of the Rings, or is it already the best representation of Tolkien's skills as a writer? 
Thanks for being the coolest classroom of people in history, 
-Emmy* 

Hobbit Society-event post(and my last post!)

I attended Hobbit societies fall speaker event where we had guest speaker, fantasy artist Eric Velhagen. I really admire his art style and the way he conveys his ideas through it. I was surprised to learn that he does not have a cellphone, he likes to seclude himself to work on his art, the flyer for his event even says “In a hole in the ground there lived and artist”. I feel that he would really appreciate the story of “ leaf by Niggle”, he seems to share some of Niggle’s characteristics. He likes to seclude himself with his art, he talked about social gatherings as an obligation, but regardless of this he is incredibly generous. I think this just goes to show how universal Tolkien’s ideas are.

Finally I would just like to say what a pleasure it was to have class with everyone, this has been the best Honors College class I have had not just because of the material and the professor but because everyone in the class always had something interesting to contribute. 

signing off for now Aule ( Aida).

Hobbit Society

Last night's Hobbit Society meeting was so incredibly interesting. Eric Velhagen was such a neat guest speaker and his art was truly exceptional. I found it really intriguing that he got into fantasy artwork by drawing scenes and characters from Tolkien's mythology and that he took inspiration from more than just Lord of the Rings. I, too, took inspiration from Tolkien when I first became serious about art, so it's very reassuring to me that others (especially successful others) drew inspiration from the same place.

Eric's work is colorful, dramatic, and dynamic. He works primarily with oil pastel (which is incredibly difficult to work with, at least in my own experience) and the chalky, almost blurry silhouettes he creates really work in his favor; adding an almost dreamlike, fantastical quality to his work. Just looking at his body of work, that quality really drew me in and made it all the more exciting for me. If you haven't had a chance to look at his art, I strongly recommend doing so while our conversations from class are still fresh in your mind. I truly feel that's when you'll appreciate his skills the most.

-Varda*

Friday, December 7, 2018

Hobbit Society: Eric Velhagen

While this evening's Hobbit Society was plagued by an extremely tardy pizza delivery, it was a fun way to end dead week. Local fantasy painter, Eric Velhagen, visited UNM to discuss his career as a professional artist and illustrator and also to show off some of work. This was a special opportunity because we got to meet one of the people behind some very impressive paintings based off of Tolkien's Legendarium. Eric showcased a few stunning renditions of the world of Middle-earth including a Nazgûl atop his flying steed, Glaurung the dragon and Arwen on her horse. It is always fun to see how people imagine Tolkien's creation might look, but it was even more fun because of the colors and poses Eric used to portray this world in his paintings. They felt alive.

Eric also had some advise for artists, which can be applied in other areas of study as well. One thing he said is that if you're feeling stuck, ask the question, "what's wrong?" Then go through the list of things that could be wrong with your piece: the color, the composition, the anatomy etc. Or you could try holding it up to a mirror to gain a new perspective. When this is done, he said, you will often see the problem right away. Another piece of advice is not to try and please everybody. Just make sure that what you've created says what you wanted it to say and leave the rest up to people who experience it. Sometimes what you think won't get much attention, does. And what you think is great, others won't like so much.

-Vairë

Tolkien's Stand Alone Stories

In this post I'd like to briefly reflect upon the stand alone stories from the Silmarillion that were edited and published by Christopher Tolkien in recent years. At this point I have read The Children of Húrin, The Fall of Gondolin and most of Beren and Lúthien.

First of all, if you're looking to continue an in depth exploration of Middle-earth, these books are a good place to do it. The Children of Húrin reads like a novel the whole way through. This makes it more enthralling because details are included in this version that were not mentioned in the Silmarillion. The Fall of Gondolin and Beren and Lúthien are comprised of multiple different versions of these stories. I especially enjoyed reading what Tolkien had in mind for Tuor's story in The Fall of Gondolin, before it was cut short during a difficult time in Tolkien's life. Still, that small chunk of very detailed story enriched my understanding and imagining of this epic story.

I would encourage you to go spend the $20-25 one of these books costs or ask Santa Claus for them. They are well worth the read.

-Vairë

Legacy Lecture: "Teaching the Human Dimension", Legacy of Human Rights

In the first presentation by Gabby Rivera (co-leading in the discovery series), she discussed the highlights and results of co-teaching the Legacy of Human Rights Course.

She began by discussing the similarity between individuals from different ethnicities and continued on to talk about making the topic of human rights personal to each student. To do this, they required personal journals be written, present music that was meaningful to them. In journals, they asked the students to report on whether they experiences any human rights abuses, and then reflect on their own morality and consistency with human rights treatment.

They also required students to come up with hypothetical solutions to current immigration issues in our country and Mexico as well as Germany and Syria to "be sent to the UN".

Further, they also had to participate in very political debates that required them to consider both sides of a given topic (typically revolving around cultural background and legal issues).

Phoebe Cummins, another honors major, focused on the misrepresentation of Latin America in the United States because of "Breaking Bad".

With an underlying interest in drug trafficing, she noticed that dealers are always unfairly depicted as Latino/Latina individuals. With this in mind, she chose "Breaking Bad" to analyze the consequences of the shows representation.

"Representation in the fictional world signifies social existence. Absence means symbolic annihilation."- George Gerbner

Phoebe discusses the lack of representation of the Latino population in television, despite being a great portion of the consumerism, and stated that when they are presented, they account for 50% of the criminals in television.

She noted that Caucasian characters in television fall into drug trafficing while Latino characters are inherently in bad business. When analyzing the Latino characters in the show, she sees that they appear less, are presented as incredibly morally corrupted, and unintelligent.

Why is this important to New Mexico?


  • 48.8% of population is Latino, but the show represents primarily Caucasians (only 3.1% if speaking roles are played by Latinos in the U.S., despite being 18% of population and 24% of ticket buying power)
  • residents of Albuquerque asked if drug involved if hispanic/male
  • residents of Albuquerque asked if feel safe if hispanic/male
  • show does bring in a lot of tourism/business/fees paid for film production
  • dehumanization of hispanics and Latinos at large



Implications for Tolkien: 

All in all, both of these students combined brought my attention, yet again to the notion of diversity in Tolkien, negative representation or representation at all, and empathy...

I think because of Tolkien's inclusion of varying species, and the conversations he wrote between Orcs and between Elves and Dwarves, readers are at least somewhat expected to question their own beliefs and explore the potential for empathy for the Orcs, since they are used as slaves. In particular, this reminded me of one of our classmates creative project (Paul's), in which he writes about warfare from the perspective of Orcs. I think Tolkien would have really appreciated that.

Thursday, December 6, 2018

Girls are amazing

Following up on Chloe's comment during class about women in writing being pretty revolutionary, I have some comments to add from my literary essay that regardad this sort of. I talked about the comparison between Elves and Spiders (specifically Shelob) and how they are actually a lot more simialr than we think on the surface. If you think about it, both Galadriel and Shelob are female, yet there are entirely different in how they are viewed. Although Shelob is almost scorned for her role, it is still interesting to think about how adding her in alongside Galariel, Eowyn, and Arwen. It adds scope and depth to female voices in a circumstance form which they are often barred or forgotten. No matter your perspective of how Tolkien handled female voices, the fact is that they are present and they are vital

{Nienna}

Relevance Post- Gollum Thoughts

This post is gonna get a bit personal y'all, so strap in and bear with me.

I have been going to see therapists for many years and I had not felt that I made significant progress until last semester and carrying into the present. I have been diagnosed with Depression, Anxiety, and PTSD and all of them have been very challenging in their own repsects, nevermind in tandem. Anyhow, I have been working mostly on my anxiety the past few weeks and felt a bit miserable thinking there was no way I could get out of it, that I was just stuck in a dark well. My therapist was aware of this class and during sessions I usually like to bring in my Tolkien coloring book (yes guys, I am able to color in not only LOTR things, but also Hobbit and Silmarillion). After telling her the way my anxiety has a voice that I usually cannot consolidate with my own, she suggested that I think of them as "Gollum thoughts"and that way I could be aware of when the bad things I am telling myself are not actually based on logic and I am not obligated to believe them.

So for several weeks, I have been a sexier version of Sméagol, telling Gollum to shut up and eat a fish every time he tells me that I am stupid or that I can't succeed and especially when he growls that nobody cares about me and I should isolate myself. I have fiund it incredibly helpful, but it has also made me wonder if that is the real reason Tolkien included Gollum/Sméagol. Was he, like me, dealing with mental illness and the onslaught of PTSD resulting from his experiences? Did he have Gollum be helpful in the end becasue he wanted to symbolically take advantage of this obstacle and push past/ use it as fuel to succeed in his own life? In any case, I am deeply aware of how important it is in my life that Tolkien wrote this character into life, because it has had a great impact on my mental health and I am deeply grateful, many decades later.

{Nienna}

Hobbit Society Meeting

This is way past due but my understanding of time is clearly non-existent. I went to the first meeting of the semester and it's all coming back at this point. The first meeting was really just everyone going around and talking about what we wanted the meetings to be this semester and exploring possible topics for discussion.

During the meeting we had an extensive discussion about the links between Sauron and Melchor, and how they seem to differ from Saruman's own behavior and goals in the context of Evil (?) or I suppose more the question of is their leaning truly evil or is it more that temptation and corruption took over a being that was already flawed and had room to be swayed one way or another.

There was also a crazy amount of talk about a sexy variation of each of the characters, stemming from the fact that Tolkien Estates is creating a new series and we were questioning what they should look like (and you know, there's definitely plenty of sexy Gandalfs out there stealing hearts left and right).

{Nienna}

Wednesday, December 5, 2018

Orc Skeleton Creative Project

Hey guys!

Here is the link to my creative project:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qdJHIMXs0UTjIouiA1hLo-CXv3WzVxeZ/view?usp=sharing

I am also attaching my explanatory essay so that you can see some of my thinking behind the changes in the Orc Skeleton. Here is the link:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zTzDRny8tOlPNYpCX6h0mee9BcxjMyt0/view?usp=sharing

If you have any questions, I would love to tell you more about it! :)

-Uinen (Annaka)


Tolkien and dedications

I know we have talked about characters in Tolkien's works reflecting his experiences and being representations of the people he cared about. Yet I have spun it round and round in my head and come to the conclusion that he leaves a lot of them out. As far as I can tell, there are no characters who are Middle-earth versions of Hilary, or any of his children. This struck me as odd since many of these stories were told to his children. One would think that a child would enjoy hearing about themselves being a hero in a mythical land, yet Tolkien (as far as we know) seems to have not even considered doing so. Did he not deem it necessary to immortalize his lifelong companion or children? Or did he simply have no interest in integrating everyone from his life into his world?

Fram and Scatha

I’ve decided to post my creative project.  Feel free to read through it if you are interested, and I would appreciate any feedback on the story.

Fram and Scatha
Fram glanced up at the sky as he saddled his horse.  The afternoon was fading into evening in the village of Éofeld.  He drew his sword and scanned the edge of the shining blade, then sheathed it and shouldered his shield.  He looked over at Dunwyn, his wife, who was tending the garden.
“I will not be gone more than three weeks,” he said.  “These wicked worms have been ravaging our lands long enough.”
“It was not like this back south, was it?” she replied, digging at the soil.
“We have good land here, fertile fields and wide pastures.  There is enough for our people.  And we are free from the menace of Mirkwood.”
“We have traded one foe for another, no less deadly,” retorted Dunwyn.
“We will slaughter the dragons,” said Fram.  “I am setting out for that very purpose.”
“It is a foolish hunt.  You will be killed.”
“How are our people to survive if we do not face these monsters?  I must go.  Where is Fastred?”
“He is in the stable.”
Fram walked over to the stable, and felt the rough-hewn beams he had raised.  Dunwyn watched him enter, then began pulling weeds out of the garden.  She did not say another word to him as he walked out, leapt astride his horse, Stormfola, and galloped away across the rolling pastures toward the mountains.

After some time Fram rode out of the fading twilight under the forest onto an open ridge of jagged rock lining the top of a hill.  There was a red sunset in the sky, and the shadows were filling in the deep valleys.  Fram smelled the pine-scented breeze and looked up toward the snow-capped mountains in the distant haze.  The last light stained their sharp horns burning orange.  
Several miles to the south he could see the warm lights of the village of Éofeld.  The fires were burning in his father’s great mead-hall, and Dunwyn and Fastred were probably just sitting down to dinner in their house.  The lights of more villages glowed softly near the horizon.
Fram turned and rode down into a densely forested valley.  He decided to find a sheltered place to set up camp for the night.  At the bottom of the slope the valley flattened and a small stream ran through it.  There were some fallen boulders forming a rough shelter there.

It was late night in Éofeld.  The soft light of the moon lay across the pastures, and the stars glimmered above.  All the lights were out in the village.  
Fastred woke suddenly to the sound of a wild neigh from the far side of the pastures.  He stood up and walked to the back door, then cracked it open and looked out towards the dark line of trees in the distance.  He froze.
There, towering above the fir-trees on the pasture’s edge, stood Scatha the Worm.  He was the greatest dragon of the Grey Mountains, a plundering terror to the Dwarves and the Éothéod alike.  His scales were silver in the moonlight and a ridge of spines ran down his wingless back.  Scatha boiled with wrath as he gazed at the village.  His eyes glowed orange with fire, and smoke issued from his nostrils.
Fastred ran over to Dunwyn’s bed.  “Mother, wake up!  There’s a dragon out there!”
Dunwyn arose startled and concerned.  “What?  A dragon?  Where?”
“Just on the edge of the fields,” said Fastred quivering.
Dunwyn arose and collected herself.  “Listen to me,” she said.  “You need to run to the Great Hall and raise the alarm.  Your grandfather is sleeping there with his warriors.  Then come back to the stable as quickly as possible.”
“What if the dragon sees me?”
“I need you to be brave,” she said.
Dunwyn watched Fastred run down the street, then stepped outside and peered around the corner of the house.  She could see the enormous dragon crawling across the fields.  His long coiling tail trailed far behind and was still partially hidden by the trees.  His gaze was fixed on the Great Hall.
She dashed across the open space to the stables, and slipped inside.  She laid her hand on Greywind, the fastest horse there, to calm him as she began to saddle him.
A horn sounded from the great hall.  After a short delay more horns replied from the other houses in the village.  The alarm spread and the village began to come alive.  Fastred came dashing down from the great hall, glancing back over his shoulder.  He ducked into the stable door.  Dunwyn beckoned him to be silent.
“Hop on Greywind,” she said.  Fastred climbed onto the saddle, and Dunwyn led the horse to the back doors of the stable.  She unlatched the door, but held it shut and waited.
A splintering crash split the night.  Fastred flinched and turned toward the great hall, but it was hidden by the stable’s wooden walls.  Dunwyn flung open the stable doors and leapt astride Greywind behind Fastred.  They galloped across the pastures.  Over the thunder of Greywind’s hooves Dunwyn heard the shouting of Frumgar’s warriors rallying against the dragon, and more horns blowing.  Scatha roared, then the clash of steel swords on scales and claws on mail rang clear.  Suddenly an orange light blanketed the pasture.  The line of trees ahead appeared bright against the dark sky, and Dunwyn felt the heat of dragon-fire at her back.  Now more distant, the cry of the warriors rallying echoed once again with the crashing and clanging.
Dunwyn and Fastred reached the line of trees, and Dunwyn turned Greywind to look back at Éofeld.  Amid the burning wreckage of the Great Hall, she saw Scatha towering over Frumgar, small figure holding a spear.  Even as she looked, Scatha struck him down and a curtain of fire obscured him from sight.  Dunwyn turned Greywind and they rode off into the forest without looking back again.

Fram awoke from an uneasy dream.  The sounds of men shouting and horns wildly blowing were still whirling in his head, but the peace of dawn lay across the land.  The sky was glowing a soft grey, and the air was still and cold.  Fram felt that something was amiss.  He packed up his camp, and rode back up to the ridge he had crossed.  When he reached the top and looked out over the lands below, he could not believe his eyes.  
The village was destroyed.  The Great Hall lay trampled and ruined, and the smoke rising from the charred houses mingled with the rising vapors from the fields.  The people of the village were gathered in the midst of the smoldering remains.  Filled with horror, Fram rode towards the ruins in haste.

Fram arrived in the town with a heavy heart.  He looked through the crowd of people, and to his relief spotted Dunwyn and Fastred.  He slipped off Stormfola, and dashed over to them.  He seized them in his arms.
“What happened?”
Dunwyn looked at him coldly.  “You were looking for dragons out there while Scatha came to our doorstep.”
Fram could not find a reply.  “Where is my father?” he asked.
Frumgar lay on a makeshift bed in a tent.  His right arm was burned badly, and there were deep gashes across his chest.  His white hair and beard were singed.
“Scatha burned our village,” he said with effort.
“I’m sorry, father.  I was not there to fight him.”
“The dragons lived in this land long before we came,” said Frumgar.  “No land is free.”
“I will slay Scatha.  We will show the worms what happens when they burn our villages.”
Frumgar stared long and hard at Fram.  Then he reached for his spear, which lay at the bedside.  He held it forth.  “Take Erkengar.  You will need it.”
Fram gripped the charred handle.  “Scatha will not live to burn another village,” he said.  “I will hunt him down and slay him.”
“Go, my son, and do not falter.  Farewell!”

Fram rode north out of Éofeld like a storm.  He would make Scatha pay for the splintered remains of the house and stables he had built, and the ravaged fields he had plowed.  Stormfola tore across the pastures and plunged into the forest.
Scatha’s trail was easy to follow.  The great worm had left a pathway of destruction.  The grass was crushed and the trees toppled in his wake, and there were deep ruts in the earth and overturned stones where he had stepped.  The signs threaded a snaking course ever northward into the unforgiving wilderness of the Grey Mountains.
After some time Fram slowed Stormfola to a steadier walk that he could sustain all day.  By the time the sun was up Éofeld had vanished between the green folds of the foothills far behind.  The hills grew steeper and more rugged, and the trees were taller and more ancient.
By mid afternoon, Scatha’s trail approached the edge of a steep gorge.  Frothy water roared through the bottom.  Fram supposed he had come upon the river his people called the Greylin, upstream of the northernmost settlements.
That night Fram camped on the rim of the canyon.  The sound of the rushing water echoed up from the cliffs, and the stars were bright in the clear sky above.

Fram picked up the trail before sunrise the next morning.  There were a number of deer gathered at one point; Scatha was far ahead.  He urged Stormfola to a faster pace.  Fram found that before long the gorge widened into a steep valley.  The mountains towered up larger and larger.  In the distance they were white, but the nearest rugged peaks were only streaked with snow. 
In the afternoon a wild thunderstorm smote the mountains.  Fram rode on through a blinding flurry of rain and hail, and the thunder boomed from the cliffs and slopes on either side of the valley.  After a short time the storm rolled off and left the trail muddy and slippery.
Fram could see that he was gaining on Scatha shortly after the storm.  The great footprints and gashes in the mud were fresh, and there was a foul reek mingled with the refreshing smell of the rain.  
That night was colder, and mists rose from the rain and wandered through the valley in the dark.  The next morning was still and calm, but Fram was on edge as he rode forward once more.  He felt Scatha’s presence near at hand, and occasionally thought he heard the echoing crash of another great spruce or fir toppling at the dragon’s feet.  Stormfola was uneasy and hesitant to proceed, but followed Fram’s stern guidance.  
After some hours, the valley widened into a flat plain edged by trees between steep mountains.  The grey cliffs and rubble slopes lined either side.  Fram paused when he saw a wide archway carved into one of the cliffs with decorative columns cut into the stone on either side.  As he approached he could see what appeared to be Dwarven runes running across the top, and long gashes in the cliff face from the dragon’s claws.
Fram tried to calm Stormfola, who nervously shifted and tried to turn about.  He was unsure of how to proceed; Scatha could be waiting around any dark corner in the cave.  Then again, Scatha might not know anything of his approach and could be sleeping atop a great pile of treasure.
Before Fram had time to make up his mind, he heard a thundering rumble from the mouth of the cave.  Stormfola turned and leapt back just as Scatha’s monstrous head appeared from the darkness.  He crawled out of the opening, his long trailing tail sliding down the steep rubble slope.  Fram maneuvered Stormfola around uphill from the dragon.
“Who are you, and what is your purpose here?” Scatha demanded, coiling around and staring at Fram with a scouring gaze.
“I am Fram son of Frumgar, and I have come to avenge the burning of my village,” shouted Fram.  “You will die for that act.”
“Your people are foolish,” hissed Scatha.  “You cannot subdue the wilderness.”
“This is our land,” said Fram, “and if you will not give us peace, we will fight for it.”
Scatha laughed.  “I plundered the Dwarves, and I raided your villages.  This is my land.”
Fram lowered his spear, and held up his shield.  “Your time is over!”  Stormfola charged down the slope towards Scatha.  Scatha raised himself up and spouted fire down upon Fram, who held his shield overhead.  Scatha roared and spun around, and Fram plunged the spear into Scatha’s tail.  A heavy blow from Scatha’s tail sent Fram hurtling off Stormfola, and onto the sharp rocks.  He pulled himself up, and Stormfola dashed for the cover of the nearest trees.  Scatha swiped at Fram, and knocked him flat on the ground again. 
Fram dropped Erkengar and his shield, and gripped Scatha’s leg with both hands.  He rose up and twisted the massive limb around, throwing it down with enormous strength.  Scatha tottered above, and the stones under his feet broke loose.  He fell and rolled down the slope, landing with a great crash on his side.  Fram seized the shield and spear again, and charged down the slope.  Scatha sent another blast of fire at Fram, and Fram held his shield in front to deflect it.  The heat was a searing pain on his face, and he could see nothing but flames all around.  The blast relented, and he dashed forward again.  He raised Erkengar, and plunged it through the dragon’s soft belly into his heart.  He felt the shaft snap and shatter.
The light flickered and faded in Scatha’s eyes.  He turned to stare at Fram.  “Your strength is great, Fram Frumgar’s son, but your father’s spear faltered just as he did,” he growled.
“My father is avenged!” shouted Fram, but Scatha’s head fell back and his limbs went limp.

Fram climbed the slope to the gateway, and picked up a broken branch kindled by Scatha’s breath.  He looked into the dark opening.  The long Dwarf-delved tunnel ran straight back deep into the mountain.  A foul stench lingered at the mouth.  Fram stepped inside, and walked down the long hallway.  The air grew more humid and stuffy, and soon doorways began opening up on either side.  He could see great black scorches across the walls, and there were tumbled fragments where the dragon had torn down the gates.  There were carvings of Dwarves along the walls, and runes which Fram could not read on either side.  
It was not long before he arrived at the end of the tunnel.  It opened into a great room delved deep in the mountain.  A heap of gold stood in the middle, and there were scattered treasures all around it.  Swords, axes, and mail gleamed dimly in the torchlight.  There were bright gemstones of various colors strewn throughout the room.  Fram could see carefully wrought cups studded with jewels, and necklaces and other jewelry.  He gasped at the extravagant wealth.

A few days later Fram rode victoriously into Éofeld on Stormfola.  He wore a coat of gilded mail, and around his neck hung the teeth of Scatha.  The people cheered as he rode in, and Dunwyn was overjoyed at his return.  
That evening he sat in a tent with Dunwyn and Fastred where his burned house had stood.
“Scatha is dead,” he said.  “Perhaps now we will have some peace from the worms for some time.”
“I am glad you made it back alive,” said Dunwyn, “though you were not unscathed.  Things could have gone ill.”
“I will journey up again in the morning with others, to retrieve the treasure.”
“Did the dragon steal the gold from the Dwarves?” asked Fastred.
“To the victor the spoils,” said Fram.  “The Dwarves did not have the valor to face Scatha.  They fled.”
Dunwyn stared at Fram.  “What are you going to do with the gold?” she asked.
“I am going to build a city,” replied Fram.  “On the wide plain where the Langflood is born of the Greylin and Langwell.  It will have stone walls, and gates and towers.  It will be safer from the plundering dragons.
“For you, Dunwyn, I brought this,” he said, producing a silver necklace of diamonds.  Dunwyn took it and held it glinting in the light, but she did not put it on.
“And for you, my son, I found this.”  Fram handed Fastred a small horn.  It was silver, and there were figures riding horses and Dwarven runes engraved along the sides.

The autumn and winter passed by.  Frumgar had recovered some of his strength, but his right arm did not mend fully.  Fram rode south to begin construction of the city, and the story of his fight with Scatha spread.  The men named the city Framsburg, and Fram’s wealth and deeds won him great renown.  Talk of the death of Scatha spread beyond the land of the Éothéod, and Dwarves conferred in their mountain halls.  
One day the next spring, Fram sat on his high seat in the Great Hall of Framsburg, a towering vaulted stone structure far greater than the quaint mead-hall Scatha destroyed in Éofeld.  To his surprise, his men escorted a party of Dwarves in who had demanded to see him.  Fram stood up and looked down at them.
The leader of the Dwarves introduced himself.  “Greetings, Fram son of Frumgar.  I am called Brúni, son of Flói.”
“Welcome to my halls, Brúni son of Flói,” replied Fram.  “What is your errand here?”
Brúni began hesitantly.  “Many years ago my grandfather, Frár, wandered the dales of the Grey Mountains.  One day he came upon a great valley lined with tall cliffs, and he called it Zigilbizâr.  He began delving a vast hall there, and there many of our people dwelt.  They called it Zigilbizâr-dûm.  The earth was rich, and they had great wealth in gold and precious stones.
“At that time, the great dragon Scatha began to trouble our people, burning the land and tearing down fortresses.  He heard of the great wealth at Zigilbizâr-dûm, and desired it for himself.  He broke in, and devoured the defenders.  Only one of our people, my companion Lofar, lived to tell the tale.
“For a hundred years the dragon Scatha has lain on the hoarded gold of our people.  Now news has reached us that you have slain Scatha the Worm, and freed Zigilbizâr-dûm from his terror.  For that we are grateful.  We now ask that you return our people’s handiwork, the treasures of the hoard, to their rightful home.  For your valor we will leave you one tenth of the spoils.”
Fram frowned.  “You would have us slay the dragons, and then take the gold for yourselves?”
Brúni did not answer.
“Dwarves have no valor!” he shouted.  “One hundred years, and you did not recover Scatha’s hoard.  The gold is mine now.”
“It rightfully belongs to our people,” replied Brúni.
“Rightfully?  Your people could not slay Scatha, but left him to ravage our pastures and villages.  You will have no gold.”  Fram then reached to his neck, and lifted off the necklace of Scatha’s teeth, which he still wore.  “Instead I offer you this gift.  Jewels such as these you will not match in your treasuries, for they are hard to come by.  Your people do not have the valor to win them on their own!”  He flung the necklace of teeth at Brúni.  A fire shouldered in Brúni’s eyes, but he made no reply.  The Dwarves turned and left.
The next day Fram rode out to scout the lands for farming around Framsburg.  He did not return, but Stormfola came into the stable riderless that night.  A man found him dead in the fields the following morning, an Orc arrow in his back.  Some said in whispered rumors that the Dwarves had loosed it, in recompense for his insult.

Dunwyn was stricken with grief.  That evening, she sat with Fastred in their house in Framsburg.
“Why did father die?” asked Fastred.
“Your father was a brave man,” replied Dunwyn.  “But he thought too highly of himself.  He thought he could fight anything.”
“He made a mistake?”
“Yes, he did.  When he killed Scatha he saved our people, but it ruined him.  Remember that.”

“I will,” said Fastred, looking at the silver horn.

~Ulmo