These are the archives from 2010-2018 for the discussion forum hosted by the UNM Hobbit Society at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, NM, USA. The purpose of our group is to meet and associate with others interested in Tolkien, and to learn more about the author, his written works, and his sources through discussion, guest lectures and academically oriented activities. This blog is intended to expand discussion among UNM Hobbit Society members beyond what meeting times allow.
Wednesday, September 30, 2015
Legend of Sigurd and Gudrun Presentation
What was the most surprising or interesting fact, idea, comment you learned from Group 3's presentation on Tolkien's Legend of Sigurd and Gudrun?
Sir Gawain Presentation
What was the most surprising or interesting fact, idea, comment you learned from Group 2's presentation on Sir Gawain and the Green Knight?
Beowulf Presentation
What was the most surprising or interesting fact, idea, comment you learned from Group 1's presentation on Tolkien's translation of Beowulf?
Monday, September 28, 2015
Gollum: How does the Ring work its evil?
The following is one of the topics from my research from last Thursday. The question came to me while I was reading "The Making of Middle Earth" section on Gollum. It struck me that there is never in clear explanation to why Smeagol was affected by the ring so strongly and so rapidly. Based on what we know about the Ring of Power it seems that Hobbits have a certain level of resistances to its evil influence. The rough explanation of why this is the case is that Hobbits are on the whole innocent creatures of simple taste. They find their greatest happiness among family, friends, nature, and peace and quiet. What then makes Smeagol different?
My nearest conclusion was Smeagol had a kind worldly desire for physical treasures that the other Hobbits do do share. The closest the other Hobbits come to this is that sense of Tookishness. Tolkien paints this as a positive desire for adventure, to experience the world for its own value and not for the treasures they might uncover along the way. Bilbo is fundamentally different from Smeagol, because his desires are those that lead to purity of the heart and soul. Smeagol's desires are center around the concept of self-gratification and thus lead to a tainted heart and soul. Thus when faced by the incredibly manipulative influence of the ring Smeagol was easily seduced by what the ring offered. Bilbo, on the other hand, was effected in a more indirect way. He saw the ring as a memento of his past adventures and a means to create new ones, therefore it required many decades to even begin to corrupt Bilbo.
This leads me to my next question. Smeagol may not have very much in common with the other Hobbits who come into contact with the ring, but he certainly is similar to the other characters who are seduced its power. Just few that come to mind immediately are Isildur, Boromir, Faramir, and Galadriel. These characters are all affected in different ways, and definitely to varying degrees. The first thing I did was to set about setting up these characters on a continuum of how much they were affected by the Ring as well as how quickly this occurred. I came to this order, first being most affected and last being least: Smeagol, Isildur, Boromir, Faramir, Galadriel.
My next goal was to determine what character trait, attributable to each of these character lead to the ring influencing them. Galadriel was influenced by the desire for the power to protect her people for evil. However, she recognized that this was not something that could be granted by the treacherous ring. It would only serve to weave further evil through her. She acknowledged that Frodo was the solo individual who could bear the ring into Mordor and thus he was the rightful bearer. Faramir was possessed by his own ego. He was so eager to earn gratification from his people and recognition from his father that he almost made the mistake of claiming the ring for his own. Only through watching the effect the ring was having on Frodo and seeing the end results in Gollum, was he able to break its grip. Boromir was similar to Faramir expect his desire came more out of personal pride to uphold the reputation he already had to solidify his place among the greatest men in history. He went further than his brother and actually attempted to take the ring from Frodo. Isildur was almost instantaneously possessed by the power of the ring. He was motivated primarily by greed. It was so pervasive that he refused to destroy it even when give the option and understanding, at least to some degree the potential consequences.
Smeagol possessed almost all of these traits, however he had one that was unique to him. Smeagol was envious. He was not only greedy but he was covetous of the possessions of others. Tolkien places this at the top of his list of great sins that the ring can feed off of. If the ring can make you feel like you are deprived and it is the entire world against you, then it is easy for control you. It is mightiest when you are isolated from the rest of the world. This was Smeagol's unfortunate fate.
From this I was able to derive a kind of order of these character's sins: Envy, Greed, Pride, Ego, Power. Additionally I would like to propose that each of the three major races outside of Hobbits has a special weakness to the ring. The Elves have their vanity, Sauron plays to this with the original plan of the rings. If it weren't for the deception of Celebrimbor, the Children of Iluvatar would have fallen into darkness. The Dwarves have their greed, their desire for gold and wealth is their downfall on multiple occasions. This is the case with the coming of the dragon Smaug, as well as the releasing of the Balrog in Moria. The Men are most affected by their desire for power. This desire is so strong and consuming that it ends up transfiguring 9 of the great kings of men into the Nazgul, the darkest, most twisted of the servants of Sauron. It is certainly a lot of information to sift through but this is my best conclusion. Thoughts?
My nearest conclusion was Smeagol had a kind worldly desire for physical treasures that the other Hobbits do do share. The closest the other Hobbits come to this is that sense of Tookishness. Tolkien paints this as a positive desire for adventure, to experience the world for its own value and not for the treasures they might uncover along the way. Bilbo is fundamentally different from Smeagol, because his desires are those that lead to purity of the heart and soul. Smeagol's desires are center around the concept of self-gratification and thus lead to a tainted heart and soul. Thus when faced by the incredibly manipulative influence of the ring Smeagol was easily seduced by what the ring offered. Bilbo, on the other hand, was effected in a more indirect way. He saw the ring as a memento of his past adventures and a means to create new ones, therefore it required many decades to even begin to corrupt Bilbo.
This leads me to my next question. Smeagol may not have very much in common with the other Hobbits who come into contact with the ring, but he certainly is similar to the other characters who are seduced its power. Just few that come to mind immediately are Isildur, Boromir, Faramir, and Galadriel. These characters are all affected in different ways, and definitely to varying degrees. The first thing I did was to set about setting up these characters on a continuum of how much they were affected by the Ring as well as how quickly this occurred. I came to this order, first being most affected and last being least: Smeagol, Isildur, Boromir, Faramir, Galadriel.
My next goal was to determine what character trait, attributable to each of these character lead to the ring influencing them. Galadriel was influenced by the desire for the power to protect her people for evil. However, she recognized that this was not something that could be granted by the treacherous ring. It would only serve to weave further evil through her. She acknowledged that Frodo was the solo individual who could bear the ring into Mordor and thus he was the rightful bearer. Faramir was possessed by his own ego. He was so eager to earn gratification from his people and recognition from his father that he almost made the mistake of claiming the ring for his own. Only through watching the effect the ring was having on Frodo and seeing the end results in Gollum, was he able to break its grip. Boromir was similar to Faramir expect his desire came more out of personal pride to uphold the reputation he already had to solidify his place among the greatest men in history. He went further than his brother and actually attempted to take the ring from Frodo. Isildur was almost instantaneously possessed by the power of the ring. He was motivated primarily by greed. It was so pervasive that he refused to destroy it even when give the option and understanding, at least to some degree the potential consequences.
Smeagol possessed almost all of these traits, however he had one that was unique to him. Smeagol was envious. He was not only greedy but he was covetous of the possessions of others. Tolkien places this at the top of his list of great sins that the ring can feed off of. If the ring can make you feel like you are deprived and it is the entire world against you, then it is easy for control you. It is mightiest when you are isolated from the rest of the world. This was Smeagol's unfortunate fate.
From this I was able to derive a kind of order of these character's sins: Envy, Greed, Pride, Ego, Power. Additionally I would like to propose that each of the three major races outside of Hobbits has a special weakness to the ring. The Elves have their vanity, Sauron plays to this with the original plan of the rings. If it weren't for the deception of Celebrimbor, the Children of Iluvatar would have fallen into darkness. The Dwarves have their greed, their desire for gold and wealth is their downfall on multiple occasions. This is the case with the coming of the dragon Smaug, as well as the releasing of the Balrog in Moria. The Men are most affected by their desire for power. This desire is so strong and consuming that it ends up transfiguring 9 of the great kings of men into the Nazgul, the darkest, most twisted of the servants of Sauron. It is certainly a lot of information to sift through but this is my best conclusion. Thoughts?
Bill Sticker
For my research topic on Thursdays class I chose to investigate a rather off handed remark the author made about Bill Stickers. In my research I found out that ‘Bill Stickers’ was the villain of a long-running Tolkien family epic- these never recorded tales were only oral in transmission and featured the hero Major Road Ahead and his everlasting struggle to persecute Bill Stickers. Bill
Stickers was actually a reference to a joke in 1960s England that came about when the government tried to stop people from putting up posters (these people being bill stickers)- someone put up a poster that added the phrase “Bill Stickers is innocent”- therefore turning a phrase into a name. It is presumed that Tolkien saw this at some point and made up his own stories featuring such ‘characters.’
Sunday, September 27, 2015
Goblins!
In popular culture, goblins are now associated with suicidal tendencies and war. However, the original goblins of the european continent were much more mischievous, frightening, and potent. I would also posit that they were more competent! Goblins evolved out of various and sundry stories, but they have these common features: they are always a small daemon, ugly in physique, and said to range in size from no bigger than a shoe to a man's hip. They were also once associated with the elves, and the Erlking, a leading figure in goblin lore, was once said to be the king of faerie. He would ride out with his wife and steal small children, eating them alive.
I have heard many goblin stories in random moments and ways. I am curious, what is your favorite type of goblin? Who is your favorite single goblin character? How do they compare to Tolkien's goblins?
I have heard many goblin stories in random moments and ways. I am curious, what is your favorite type of goblin? Who is your favorite single goblin character? How do they compare to Tolkien's goblins?
Blood Moon
Tonight, a red mood greeted the earth. It did not linger, lasting only a mere hour, but it left its mark. Thinking of the blood moon, and of Tolkien's concept art of the surface of the moon, I beheld this spectacle with a question in mind: What makes Tolkien's concept of enchantment inherent to things? A fog appears and Frodo is lost in the barrows, Tom Bombadil sings away old trees. Why do these things have power? What is "enchantment," and how is it natural. Perhaps the blood moon will prompt your answers to these questions, or simply enchant you for its hour on earth.
Valkyries
The subject of the Valkyries came up in class on Tuesday, and I chose this as my topic for research on Thursday. They are only mentioned very briefly in The Prose Edda. It tells us that "they are sent by Odin to every battle, where they choose which men are to die and they determine who has the victory. Gunn and Rota and the youngest norn, named Skuld, always ride to choose the slain and to decide the outcome of the battle." This is all we really know about them from The Prose Edda.
I was interested to learn that there is dispute over what their name actually means. The name is translated "chooser of the slain." Some translations hold that they actually go into battle to choose who dies and who lives. Others say that they look over those who are slain and decide who gets to return with them to Valhalla. The name can mean either. Some sources that I looked up said one or the other, but some said that they perform both tasks. The only other thing we know for sure about them is that when the slain are not preparing for Ragnarok, the Valkyries serve them mead. Overall, the controversy over the name is was what really piqued my interest. It reminds me of how someone misinterpreted a part of the Old Testament and thought that Moses had two horns coming out of his head. As a result, Moses has often been depicted this way.
I've tried to think of other figures in mythology that resemble the Valkyries in hopes that we can get a clue at what they were intended to be. However, I cannot seem the think of any. In most cultures, someone who brings death is depicted as dark and scary, like the Grim Reaper. But the Valkyries seem less ominous and more like caregivers. After all, they spend their downtime serving alcohol to dead guys. Perhaps this is a clue in itself. Since they are more like caregivers, maybe it is more likely that they do not decide who dies but only choose among the slain.
I was interested to learn that there is dispute over what their name actually means. The name is translated "chooser of the slain." Some translations hold that they actually go into battle to choose who dies and who lives. Others say that they look over those who are slain and decide who gets to return with them to Valhalla. The name can mean either. Some sources that I looked up said one or the other, but some said that they perform both tasks. The only other thing we know for sure about them is that when the slain are not preparing for Ragnarok, the Valkyries serve them mead. Overall, the controversy over the name is was what really piqued my interest. It reminds me of how someone misinterpreted a part of the Old Testament and thought that Moses had two horns coming out of his head. As a result, Moses has often been depicted this way.
I've tried to think of other figures in mythology that resemble the Valkyries in hopes that we can get a clue at what they were intended to be. However, I cannot seem the think of any. In most cultures, someone who brings death is depicted as dark and scary, like the Grim Reaper. But the Valkyries seem less ominous and more like caregivers. After all, they spend their downtime serving alcohol to dead guys. Perhaps this is a clue in itself. Since they are more like caregivers, maybe it is more likely that they do not decide who dies but only choose among the slain.
Tricksters and Tolkien
In my research, I was most curious
about the nature of the Trickster and how it might have been represented in
other characters through history—especially Tolkien’s characters.
Through my research I found out
that the fundamental traits of a trickster are that they are morally ambiguous
(untethered to either "good" or "evil”), deceptive, fond of
tricks, and either quite sly or very naïve.
In addition, they tend to be shape-shifters (like Loki) and
shallow. Their primary goals are
self-preservation and general chaos, so they are both cowardly and solitary. Thus, in order to avoid punishment, they are
often both the cause and the resolution of problems.
Once I found all of this
information, it was easy to find examples in literature and culture: the Joker,
Pan the Satyr, Woland the devil, Rumpelstiltskin, and the “Seven With One Blow”
tailor. These examples demonstrate how
wide this category can be; the Joker and Woland are certainly more on the evil
side, but the tailor is the protagonist of his story.
Before my research, I had thought
that Grima and Saruman were probably the best examples of a Trickster in
Tolkien’s works, but after looking at the definition of the Trickster, I
realized that Smeagol is a great example of a Trickster.
Smeagol is solitary, shallow,
selfish, and (while malicious) he is not evil or good. He is not on anyone’s side but his own, as is
demonstrated by his betrayal of Frodo as soon as he feels threatened. As to shape-changing, he has the One Ring to
make him invisible, and he is very sly.
In fact, he uses the word “tricksy” more than once, and his antics drive
the plot forward in many points.
I find Smeagol to be the most
convincing Trickster in Tolkien’s works; what do you think?
Saturday, September 26, 2015
Dragons!
The topic I was curious about and chose to focus on researching during Thursday's class was dragons. The Making of Middle-earth chapter had a specific section about dragons that sparked my curiosity.
Dragons play an important role in many of Tolkien's works, specifically The Hobbit, The Silmarillion, and The Children of Hurín. I've always been particularly interested in dragons, especially after an Animal Planet documentary had me convinced for an hour that they had found a real dragon. Therefore, some of the questions I had heading into my research were as follows:
Why are dragons often the enemy?
Why doesn't anyone ride a dragon in Tolkien's world?
Why are there talking dragons in Tolkien's world but none of them are nice?
What I found during my research:
Dragons were initially though of as akin to any exotic beast i.e. a lion, tiger, etc. But then Christianity came about as a forceful worldview, particularly in Europe. Once Christianity took hold dragons became synonymous with the idea of evil and were viewed as sinister beings. Thereafter the depictions of dragons began to conform to the expectations of the era. Dragons were then largely placed in stories and mythology as a foil to a righteous hero. Fire breathing dragons are thought to have originated with the idea of a "hell mouth". Many depictions of hell and demons include being consumed by fire via a hell mouth. Thus, a fire breathing dragon is akin to the fire from the pit of hell. Another interesting fact is the etymology of "dragon". It comes from the Greek word "draconta" (which is also connected with the Latin word Draco) which means "to watch". Therefore, it is thought that this etymology is connected to the idea of dragons "watching (guarding) valuables".
How I connected this to my initial questions:
I think Tolkien's dragons may be uniformly sinister because they follow the line of dragons viewed through the Christian worldview. The dragons in Tolkien's world are created by Morgoth and therefore are unlikely to have any redeemable qualities. They were created and raised up in evil and exist to antagonize the heroes in Tolkien's tales. Tolkien's dragons are also different from each other. For example, Glaurung is wingless while Smaug has wings. Apparently dragon fire is also capable of destroying the rings of power, except for the One ring. Interesting right? I could not find much about why Tolkien refers to dragons as "the great worm". Any one else have any thoughts on why dragons are evil worms? Or why there are no dragon riders in Tolkien works? Any thoughts on why dragon fire cannot destroy the One ring?
Dragons play an important role in many of Tolkien's works, specifically The Hobbit, The Silmarillion, and The Children of Hurín. I've always been particularly interested in dragons, especially after an Animal Planet documentary had me convinced for an hour that they had found a real dragon. Therefore, some of the questions I had heading into my research were as follows:
Why are dragons often the enemy?
Why doesn't anyone ride a dragon in Tolkien's world?
Why are there talking dragons in Tolkien's world but none of them are nice?
What I found during my research:
Dragons were initially though of as akin to any exotic beast i.e. a lion, tiger, etc. But then Christianity came about as a forceful worldview, particularly in Europe. Once Christianity took hold dragons became synonymous with the idea of evil and were viewed as sinister beings. Thereafter the depictions of dragons began to conform to the expectations of the era. Dragons were then largely placed in stories and mythology as a foil to a righteous hero. Fire breathing dragons are thought to have originated with the idea of a "hell mouth". Many depictions of hell and demons include being consumed by fire via a hell mouth. Thus, a fire breathing dragon is akin to the fire from the pit of hell. Another interesting fact is the etymology of "dragon". It comes from the Greek word "draconta" (which is also connected with the Latin word Draco) which means "to watch". Therefore, it is thought that this etymology is connected to the idea of dragons "watching (guarding) valuables".
How I connected this to my initial questions:
I think Tolkien's dragons may be uniformly sinister because they follow the line of dragons viewed through the Christian worldview. The dragons in Tolkien's world are created by Morgoth and therefore are unlikely to have any redeemable qualities. They were created and raised up in evil and exist to antagonize the heroes in Tolkien's tales. Tolkien's dragons are also different from each other. For example, Glaurung is wingless while Smaug has wings. Apparently dragon fire is also capable of destroying the rings of power, except for the One ring. Interesting right? I could not find much about why Tolkien refers to dragons as "the great worm". Any one else have any thoughts on why dragons are evil worms? Or why there are no dragon riders in Tolkien works? Any thoughts on why dragon fire cannot destroy the One ring?