These are the archives from 2010-2018 for the discussion forum hosted by the UNM Hobbit Society at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, NM, USA. The purpose of our group is to meet and associate with others interested in Tolkien, and to learn more about the author, his written works, and his sources through discussion, guest lectures and academically oriented activities. This blog is intended to expand discussion among UNM Hobbit Society members beyond what meeting times allow.
Thursday, March 31, 2011
As we continue to discuss the importance of treasure in Beowulf, I am constantly reminded of Smaug's horde in The Hobbit. Treasure plays an enormous role in both stories, both as a goal for the protagonists and heroes and as a bane. The stolen treasure of the Dwarves was more important to Thorin than peace between the Lonely Mountain and its neighbors, and this stance cost him his life in the end. While Beowulf was mortally wounded by the dragon itself while protecting his people and kingdom, the allure of the dragon's horde must be taken into consideration. If there had been no horde, would Beowulf have still attempted to face the dragon alone? We will never know...
Overall Impression of "Beowulf"
I'm curious as to what you're impressions of "Beowulf" were. I didn't enjoy it all that much, but I'm interested to know why you liked it (if any of you did). The character of Beowulf seemed a little too cocky and self-assured to me. Maybe that was valued in their culture, but I find it very off-putting. Beowulf can be compared to Aragorn because they are both good fighters and become kings, but Aragorn is much more likable because he is so humble. Does this make Aragorn a better king than Beowulf?
Tuesday, March 29, 2011
Today in our discussion, we talked about the different ways in which our perception of "Elves" has changed throughout history and from culture to culture. In Beowulf, Elves are perceived as among the evil races of ghosts, ogres, and monsters. Dr. Donovan also brought up the interesting concept of separating Elves into two categories; Good Elves and Dark Elves. If any of you have read any of the Forgotten Realms books by R.A. Salvatore, you will be familiar with this race of Dark Elves. These are the Drow, the evil race of Elves that lives below ground, and are affected adversely by light. They are an evil and corrupt race, venturing above ground only during the cover of night to raid and plunder. I find the connection between Salvatore's Drow and Dr. Donovan's description of the Norse Dark Elves quite intriguing.
Age affects values?
The individualism constantly displayed in Beowulf reminds me of Eomer’s battle with Ugluk. I remember from LOTR that Eomer actually dismounted his horse and fought Ugluk one-on-one. I also think it is interesting that Eomer is young. By contrast, I cannot think of one time where Aragorn (older royalty) decides to fight alone unless he absolutely has to. The only time I recall Aragorn fighting somewhat alone is against the black riders at WhetherTop, but it is not like he had an army behind him (as Eomer did). It was brought up in class that Beowulf seems individualistic as a youth and then more open to collaboration in his attempt to protect his people in his older age. I feel like Beowulf fighting Grendel and Eomer fighting Ugluk alone (despite having armies to aid them) shows that pride and glory are important for younger men to have in these warrior societies (in both LOTR and Beowulf). As Beowulf gets older (and wiser) he becomes more similar to Aragorn. Despite the fact that they both make kingly transformations, I think that the older Beowulf and Aragorn are more open to working with others if it means a better chance to protect their people (or the world in LOTR). Instead of hard-earned glory and pride, it is more important for the success of their people (or good in LOTR). Youth = acting on pride? Age = Wisdom = collaboration overpowering pride?
Lord of the Rings vs. Beowulf
So, I'm kind of combining two of the main ideas that we did freewrites about in class today: "community and social groups" and "loyalty and honor". I think that it's interesting that Lord of the Rings seems to have more of an emphasis on loyalty whereas beowulf has it's emphasis on honor. I also think that this goes hand in hand with the theme of community in the stories. Lord of the Rings also emphasizes community more in my opinion. This would make sense that when emphasizing community, there is also emphasis on loyalty. When in a community, people need to be loyal and trust each other to get a job done. I think this is shown especially in the fellowship. They were a community with a single purpose. They were loyal to each other and trusted each other, and even though Frodo was the ring-bearer, the others in the fellowship played a huge part in helping him. However, in Beowulf, it seems that the individual is stressed more than the community. It also makes sense that when there is emphasis on honor, individualism is stressed. Even though Beowulf had his 15 men with him to help him, they didn't do anything but watch, until the very end when Wiglaf helped him with the dragon. The focus was really on the individual and what he could do rather than on the group.
Monday, March 28, 2011
Beowulf vs Frodo
So, one main difference between the Lord of the Rings and Beowulf that I noticed are who the antagonists are and how they act. Was anyone else really bothered by how arrogant Beowulf is? I mean, cool, you killed Grendel, but you don't have to brag about it. I think this is why people like Frodo and all of the other main characters in the Lord of the Rings better. They do what they do to help Middle-earth--not to prove how strong they are.
Fairy stories for adults?
Tolkien argues that fairy stories should be for adults as well.The original versions of modern fairy tales would support this view. The original version were much more gruesome than the Disney versions. For example, the original version of Cinderella included a lot more blood than the Disney version.
boudries
In classic fairy stories,magical creatures are either incorporated in the world of the main characters or have a separate world of their own. The boundary is usually unclear and only open to those chosen. Does this mean only specific people are worthy to see such a world. Does this reflect any ideas of how humans should be like to be worthy of special knowledge of such worlds.
Over the weekend, I read Beowulf and decided to watch the recent cartoon version (starring Angelina Jolie) just to compare it to the original story. I was pleasantly surprised with the movie and its connection with the original plot. While the film does deviate from the plot, the basic outline of the tale remains very similar. The main addition to the story is the inclusion of female interaction within. In the written tale, women play a very small role, but in modern film, the female aspect is greatly enlarged. Because it is a 21st century film, there is also a large amount of sexual content that is added to spice up the storyline. This seemed to be one of the largest deviations, and did work to change some aspects of the story drastically. Overall, I was pleasantly surprised with the movie, as I was expecting an abomination of a film. Perhaps for purists, this is a horrible interpretation, but I found that it told the majority of the story accurately while staying in tune with the original plot. Thoughts? Criticisms?
Sunday, March 27, 2011
Eucatastrophe
One characteristic of a modern fairy-story we discussed briefly last week has to do with the "happy ending." Near the end of "On Fairy-stories," Tolkien discusses his idea of the eucatastrophe. Write about your thoughts on this idea, and how this idea relates to the concept of the happy ending. Are "eucatastrophe" and "happy ending" synonymous? Do modern fairy-stories and fantasy works of any medium tend to contain this idea of eucatastrophe, or of happy ending, or both? Or neither?
Labels:
eucatastrophe,
happy ending,
on fairy-stories