Pages

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Dwarves and Elves

This is something that's been fascinating me for a while. I wonder if anyone would like to discuss the relationship between Dwarves and Elves. The animosity and vague class snobbery present is a little fascinating, particularly on the part of the Elves. I mean, a race that's supposed to be wise and immortal and ever-sage or whatever should have grown out of such prejudices by now. Yet they haven't. Now, I already know the reasons behind their initial distrust, but I wonder what Tolkien meant to do with that point. It probably ties into the sociopolitical issues that we discussed in the Council of Elrond exercise last class, but I would be interested in hearing what everyone else thought

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

C.S. Lewis & Tolkien

As I was reading the Fellowship this week, I noticed off hand in Chapter XI that Tolkien mentions the insects that stung the travelers mercilessly as they trekked towards Rivendell. They are portrayed as quite annoying and hostile, and Sam names them "Neekerbreekers." He wonders what they eat when Hobbits aren't on the menu. As I read this, I immediately thought back to C.S. Lewis's Narnia, specifically Prince Caspian. In Prince Caspian, one of the dwarves is named Nikabrik. He is portrayed as annoying, bad tempered, and treacherous. Later in the book, Nikabrik betrays Prince Caspian and allies himself with the evil races. I know that Tolkien and Lewis were peers, and if this similarity of name and character is purposeful, or simply a coincidence? Thoughts?

DIfferent Points of View

I think today's Council of Elrond exercise was very instrumental in helping solidify the characters of the books. There are many different characters throughout the books with their own unique points of view, and it may be hard to keep them all straight. Going through each character's motivations really helps to better understand their actions later in the story as well as better appreciate Tolkien's works of art. He really took the time to craft each character with their own personality, motivation, and quirks. I think it is really cool that there are little to no stock characters in the books.

Elladan

Hello all, I finally got around to figuring out my pseudonym. I am Elladan, son of Elrond, brother of Arwen and Elrohir. Throughout the Fellowship, I am often off on extensive scouting journeys, bringing back information to Imladris. Unfortunately, I don't play any major role throughout the trilogy, although some speculate that my brother Elrohir and I, like our sister Arwen, chose to stay in Middle Earth after the fall of Sauron and live out our days as Mortal Men.

Monday, February 7, 2011

The enemy of my enemy is my friend

Throughout the lord of the rings despite their differences different races come together to fight for their lives. This truly exemplifies the ability of different races , perhaps representing humankind, to come together for a common cause. Perhaps Tolkien also was trying to say that petty human differences are of almost no importance when it comes to all living things.

Can't judge a book by its cover

Even though I am new to this author, nothing in this book is what it seems. Everything seems to have a underlying background beneath the surface. Some examples of this is Aragorn, Gandolf, Bilbo, and the ring itself. The only part that is clear cut evil is Mordor.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Lust for power, or evil nature?

In the Lord of the Rings, great and mostly benevolent people are either warned against using the ring or refuse to wield it based on their own wisdom. Gandalf is a notable example. I was considering the following question: does Tolkien believe that too great of power inevitably corrupts even the best intentions or is the ring simply an evil power that hijacks the will of the good? Strong evidence exists for the for the former. When Boromir suggests using the ring for good, Elrond replies "Alas, no... It belongs to Sauron... and is altogether evil." However, later in the passage he suggests that Saruman was corrupted by mere lust for the ring. This seems more ambiguous. Either the ring acts over any distance if only thought it bent on it or Saruman turned evil just by lust of power. I feel that it may be a combination of those too explanations and more. If anyone wants to share opinions the passage I looked at that has a lot of dialogue pertaining to this is about 30 paragraphs from the end of "The Council of Elrond."

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Forests

We started to talk about this a little bit in class today, but I find it interesting that all of the forests in both The Hobbit and the LOTR, seem to be personified as evil. In the Hobbit, Mirkwood is very sinister and full of dark creatures. Already in FotR, we see that the Old Forest attacks the hobbits. And later on, Fangorn is always portrayed as evil and dark, and people want to avoid it. I wonder why this is. The trees are like a whole other people group in the story (in the same way that Tolkien personified animals). This might just be in the movie, but I know that Treebeard said something to the effect of: "We aren't on any side, because no one is on our side. No one cares for the trees anymore." So, maybe it is an environmental sort of message that we need to care for the trees, but it's an interesting topic to think about.

More than just luck?

Destiny is prevalent throughout the Fellowship of the Ring. In Chapter II of Book I, Gandalf reasons, “Bilbo was meant to find the ring, and not by its maker. In which case, you were also meant to have it.” When the Black Riders first approached Frodo, the narrator conveyed that “a sudden desire to hide from view of the rider came over him.” “When the Hobbits set out from the shire, they met Elves: “Our paths cross theirs seldom, by chance or purpose.” When Frodo asked if Bombadil heard him calling he replied, “Just chance brought me then, if chance you call it.” In Chapter XII of Book I, Aragon expresses, “There my heart is; but it is not my fate to sit in peace, even in the fair house of Elrond.” Destiny is also used in foreshadowing; Gandalf exclaims (in the Council of Elrond), “But he (Gollum) may play a part that neither he nor Sauron have forseen.” In some cases, Tolkien even uses this theme of destiny to foreshadow things to come. Tolkien really seems to emphasize that everything (good or bad) happens for a reason (not by mere luck alone).

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

In honor of the snow...




Here are depictions of the snowy, dangerous Pass of Caradhras, painted by Alan Lee and John Howe. In The Lord of the Rings, the Fellowship passes through the Mines of Moria to avoid Caradhras, which doesn't turn out well at all...